School of Health Sciences, University of South Australia, GPO box 2471, Adelaide, 5001, Australia.
Alliance for Research in Exercise, Nutrition and Activity (ARENA), Sansom Institute for Health Research, University of South Australia, GPO Box 2471, Adelaide, 5001, Australia.
BMC Med Educ. 2017 Aug 10;17(1):133. doi: 10.1186/s12909-017-0973-5.
Using simulated learning environments with standardised patients (SPs) provides a way to scaffold the development of skills for patient safety in a low risk environment. There are no data regarding whether adding SP interactions in early years of physiotherapy training improves safe performance on clinical placement. We assessed the feasibility of recruiting and collecting data from junior physiotherapy students during an SP workshop with a pilot non-randomised trial, also assessing time, cost and scheduling information.
Second year physiotherapy students were invited to participate and allocated to either the SP workshop in a simulated hospital environment (with and without video feedback) or usual teaching comprising peer role play. The main outcome measures were participant recruitment, retention and survey response rates, whether the training and workshops were delivered as scheduled and costs for SPs and staff training and workshop attendance. Students self-reported confidence, communication, preparedness for clinic and satisfaction was measured using pre-post surveys.
The pilot trial proved feasible, with 108 students recruited (100%) and high retention (95%) and survey response rates (85%). The training sessions and SP workshops were delivered as scheduled, costing $4700AUD. Students rated their confidence and preparedness for clinical placement higher post intervention (p < 0.001) with high levels of satisfaction with the SP interactions (mean score 9.3/10).
In this setting the SP workshop was feasible. Further research incorporating a randomised trial investigating the integration of SPs for the development and assessment of patient safety skills in physiotherapy education is recommended.
ANZCTR no: 12,615,000,686,505.
使用标准化患者(SP)模拟学习环境为在低风险环境中培养患者安全技能提供了一种方法。目前尚不清楚在物理治疗培训的早期阶段增加 SP 互动是否会提高临床实习中的安全表现。我们评估了在 SP 研讨会中招募和收集二年级物理治疗学生数据的可行性,采用了一项初步非随机试验,同时还评估了时间、成本和时间表信息。
邀请二年级物理治疗学生参加,并将其分配到模拟医院环境中的 SP 研讨会(有和没有视频反馈)或包含同伴角色扮演的常规教学中。主要观察指标为参与者的招募、保留和调查回复率、培训和研讨会是否按计划进行以及 SP 和工作人员培训和参加研讨会的成本。学生使用预-后调查自我报告信心、沟通、临床准备情况和满意度。
试点试验证明是可行的,共招募了 108 名学生(100%),保留率和调查回复率均较高(95%和 85%)。培训课程和 SP 研讨会按计划进行,成本为 4700 澳元。学生在干预后对自己的临床实习准备情况和信心评价更高(p<0.001),对 SP 互动的满意度也很高(平均得分 9.3/10)。
在这种情况下,SP 研讨会是可行的。建议进行进一步的研究,纳入随机试验,调查将 SP 整合到物理治疗教育中以开发和评估患者安全技能的效果。
澳大利亚新西兰临床试验注册中心:12,615,000,686,505。