Hollingsworth Clare E, Wesley Carla, Huckridge Jaymie, Finn Gabrielle M, Griksaitis Michael J
Paediatric Intensive Care Unit, Southampton Children's Hospital, Southampton, UK.
Child and Adolescent Mental Health Service, London, UK.
Arch Dis Child. 2018 Jan;103(1):14-18. doi: 10.1136/archdischild-2017-313544. Epub 2017 Aug 18.
To assess the prevalence of symptoms of acute stress reactions (ASR) and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in paediatric trainees following their involvement in child death.
A survey designed to identify trainees' previous experiences of child death combined with questions to identify features of PTSD. Quantitative interpretation was used alongside a χ test. A p value of <0.05 was considered significant.
604 surveys were distributed across 13 UK health education deaneries.
303/604 (50%) of trainees completed the surveys.
251/280 (90%) of trainees had been involved with the death of a child, although 190/284 (67%) had no training in child death. 118/248 (48%) of trainees were given a formal debrief session following their most recent experience. 203/251 (81%) of trainees reported one or more symptoms or behaviours that could contribute to a diagnosis of ASR/PTSD. 23/251 (9%) of trainees met the complete criteria for ASR and 13/251 (5%) for PTSD. Attending a formal debrief and reporting feelings of guilt were associated with an increase in diagnostic criteria for ASR/PTSD (p=0.036 and p<0.001, respectively).
Paediatric trainees are at risk of developing ASR and PTSD following the death of a child. The feeling of guilt should be identified and acknowledged to allow prompt signposting to further support, including psychological assessment or intervention if required. Clear recommendations need to be made about the safety of debriefing sessions as, in keeping with existing evidence, our data suggest that debrief after the death of a child may be associated with the development of symptoms suggestive of ASR/PTSD.
评估参与儿童死亡事件的儿科实习医生中急性应激反应(ASR)和创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)症状的发生率。
一项旨在识别实习医生以往儿童死亡经历的调查,并结合用于识别PTSD特征的问题。采用定量解释并辅以χ检验。p值<0.05被视为具有统计学意义。
向英国13个健康教育地区分发了604份调查问卷。
604名实习医生中有303名(50%)完成了调查。
280名实习医生中有251名(90%)参与过儿童死亡事件,尽管284名中有190名(67%)未接受过儿童死亡相关培训。248名实习医生中有118名(48%)在最近一次经历后接受了正式的情况汇报。251名实习医生中有203名(81%)报告了一种或多种可能有助于诊断ASR/PTSD的症状或行为。251名实习医生中有23名(9%)符合ASR的完整标准,13名(5%)符合PTSD的完整标准。参加正式的情况汇报和报告内疚感与ASR/PTSD诊断标准的增加相关(p值分别为0.036和<0.001)。
儿科实习医生在儿童死亡后有患ASR和PTSD的风险。应识别并承认内疚感,以便及时提供进一步的支持,包括在需要时进行心理评估或干预。需要就情况汇报会的安全性提出明确建议,因为根据现有证据,我们的数据表明,儿童死亡后的情况汇报可能与ASR/PTSD相关症状的发展有关。