Veenema Tener Goodwin, Thornton Clifton P, Lavin Roberta Proffitt, Bender Annah K, Seal Stella, Corley Andrew
Beta Nu, Associate Professor, School of Nursing, Department Acute and Chronic Care, Johns Hopkins School of Nursing Center for Humanitarian Health, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, USA.
Beta Nu, Clinical Nurse Practitioner, The Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Johns Hopkins Charlotte Bloomberg Children's Hospital, Baltimore, MD, USA.
J Nurs Scholarsh. 2017 Nov;49(6):625-634. doi: 10.1111/jnu.12328. Epub 2017 Aug 18.
Rising global temperatures have resulted in an increased frequency and severity of cyclones, hurricanes, and flooding in many parts of the world. These climate change-related water disasters (CCRWDs) have a devastating impact on communities and the health of residents. Clinicians and policymakers require a substantive body of evidence on which to base planning, prevention, and disaster response to these events. The purpose of this study was to conduct a systematic review of the literature concerning the impact of CCRWDs on public health in order to identify factors in these events that are amenable to preparedness and mitigation. Ultimately, this evidence could be used by nurses to advocate for greater preparedness initiatives and inform national and international disaster policy.
A systematic literature review of publications identified through a comprehensive search of five relevant databases (PubMed, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature [CINAHL], Embase, Scopus, and Web of Science) was conducted using a modified Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) approach in January 2017 to describe major themes and associated factors of the impact of CCRWDs on population health.
Three major themes emerged: environmental disruption resulting in exposure to toxins, population susceptibility, and health systems infrastructure (failure to plan-prepare-mitigate, inadequate response, and lack of infrastructure). Direct health impact was characterized by four major categories: weather-related morbidity and mortality, waterborne diseases/water-related illness, vector-borne and zoonotic diseases, and psychiatric/mental health effects. Scope and duration of the event are factors that exacerbate the impact of CCRWDs. Discussion of specific factors amenable to mitigation was limited. Flooding as an event was overrepresented in this analysis (60%), and the majority of the research reviewed was conducted in high-income or upper middle-/high-income countries (62%), despite the fact that low-income countries bear a disproportionate share of the burden on morbidity and mortality from CCRWDs.
Empirical evidence related to CCRWDs is predominately descriptive in nature, characterizing the cascade of climatic shifts leading to major environmental disruption and exposure to toxins, and their resultant morbidity and mortality. There is inadequate representation of research exploring potentially modifiable factors associated with CCRWDs and their impact on population health. This review lays the foundation for a wide array of further areas of analysis to explore the negative health impacts of CCRWDs and for nurses to take a leadership role in identifying and advocating for evidence-based policies to plan, prevent, or mitigate these effects.
Nurses comprise the largest global healthcare workforce and are in a position to advocate for disaster preparedness for CCRWDs, develop more robust environmental health policies, and work towards mitigating exposure to environmental toxins that may threaten human health.
全球气温上升导致世界许多地区气旋、飓风和洪水的发生频率增加、强度加大。这些与气候变化相关的水灾害(CCRWDs)对社区及居民健康产生了毁灭性影响。临床医生和政策制定者需要大量证据来为针对这些事件的规划、预防及灾害应对提供依据。本研究的目的是对有关CCRWDs对公众健康影响的文献进行系统综述,以确定这些事件中适合进行准备和缓解的因素。最终,护士可利用这些证据来倡导更多的准备举措,并为国家和国际灾害政策提供信息。
2017年1月,采用改良的系统评价和Meta分析优先报告项目(PRISMA)方法,对通过全面检索五个相关数据库(PubMed、护理学与健康相关文献累积索引数据库[CINAHL]、Embase、Scopus和科学引文索引)所识别的出版物进行系统文献综述,以描述CCRWDs对人群健康影响的主要主题及相关因素。
出现了三个主要主题:环境破坏导致接触毒素、人群易感性以及卫生系统基础设施(规划 - 准备 - 缓解不足、应对不力和基础设施缺乏)。直接健康影响的特征分为四大类:与天气相关的发病和死亡、水传播疾病/与水相关的疾病、媒介传播和人畜共患疾病以及精神/心理健康影响。事件的范围和持续时间是加剧CCRWDs影响的因素。关于适合缓解的具体因素的讨论有限。在该分析中,洪水事件的占比过高(60%),并且所审查的大多数研究是在高收入或中高/高收入国家进行的(62%),尽管低收入国家承受着CCRWDs导致的发病率和死亡率的不成比例的负担。
与CCRWDs相关的实证证据主要是描述性的,描述了导致重大环境破坏和接触毒素的一系列气候变化及其导致的发病率和死亡率。探索与CCRWDs及其对人群健康影响相关的潜在可改变因素的研究代表性不足。本综述为一系列进一步的分析领域奠定了基础,以探讨CCRWDs的负面健康影响,也为护士在识别和倡导基于证据的政策以规划、预防或减轻这些影响方面发挥领导作用奠定了基础。
护士是全球最大的医疗保健劳动力群体,有能力倡导针对CCRWDs的灾害准备工作,制定更有力的环境卫生政策,并努力减少接触可能威胁人类健康的环境毒素。