Department of Nutritional Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, 150 College Street, Toronto, M5S 3E2, Canada.
Department of Nutritional Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, 150 College Street, Toronto, M5S 3E2, Canada.
Appetite. 2018 Jan 1;120:92-99. doi: 10.1016/j.appet.2017.08.020. Epub 2017 Aug 24.
This study investigated the effects of adding monosodium glutamate (MSG) to carrot soup with or without whey protein, on subjective appetite, food intake (FI) and satiety hormones in healthy young men.
Two experiments were conducted using a repeated-measures, within-subject, crossover design. In exp-1 healthy young men (n = 28) consumed water alone (500 mL), or carrot soup (500 g) with or without MSG (5 g, 1% w/w) or whey protein enriched (36 g) carrot soup with or without MSG (5 g, 1% w/w). Subjective appetite was measured post-treatment and FI measured at a meal at 120 min. In exp-2 (n = 15) the same treatments except for water were used. In addition to subjective appetite and FI, blood glucose, insulin, glucose like peptide 1 (GLP-1), C-peptide and ghrelin were measured.
Adding MSG to carrot soup or whey protein enriched carrot soup did not affect FI. However, in exp-1 the addition of both MSG and protein increased fullness, and when MSG was added to carrot soup reduced desire to eat. In exp-2, average post-treatment appetite (5-120 min) was lower after carrot soup with MSG and protein than all other treatments (P < 0.05). In exp-2, carrot soup with MSG and protein, but not with protein alone, increased post-treatment insulin and C-peptide, and lowered blood glucose in comparison to carrot soup with no additions (P < 0.05).
Adding MSG alone, or in combination with whey protein, to carrot soups did not affect FI. However, MSG increased fullness and reduced desire to eat, as well as subjective appetite, and when added to protein decreased blood glucose and increased insulin and C-peptide, offering some support for the hypothesis that MSG in the gut signals protein consumption.
本研究旨在探讨在胡萝卜汤中添加味精(MSG)对健康年轻男性的主观食欲、食物摄入量(FI)和饱腹感激素的影响。
采用重复测量、个体内交叉设计进行了两项实验。在实验 1 中,28 名健康年轻男性(n=28)分别饮用纯水(500 毫升)、胡萝卜汤(500 克)以及添加或不添加 MSG(5 克,1%w/w)或富含乳清蛋白(36 克)的添加或不添加 MSG 的胡萝卜汤。在治疗后测量主观食欲,并在 120 分钟时测量进餐时的食物摄入量。在实验 2(n=15)中,除了使用水外,还使用了相同的处理方法。除了主观食欲和食物摄入量外,还测量了血糖、胰岛素、葡萄糖样肽 1(GLP-1)、C 肽和胃饥饿素。
在胡萝卜汤或富含乳清蛋白的胡萝卜汤中添加 MSG 并不影响 FI。然而,在实验 1 中,添加 MSG 和蛋白质均增加了饱腹感,而当 MSG 添加到胡萝卜汤中时,降低了进食欲望。在实验 2 中,添加 MSG 和蛋白质的胡萝卜汤处理后的平均(5-120 分钟)食欲低于其他所有处理(P<0.05)。在实验 2 中,添加 MSG 和蛋白质的胡萝卜汤,而不是仅添加蛋白质的胡萝卜汤,与无添加物的胡萝卜汤相比,增加了治疗后的胰岛素和 C 肽,并降低了血糖(P<0.05)。
单独或与乳清蛋白结合在胡萝卜汤中添加 MSG 并不影响 FI。然而,MSG 增加了饱腹感和降低了进食欲望,以及主观食欲,当与蛋白质一起添加时,降低了血糖并增加了胰岛素和 C 肽,这为 MSG 在肠道中发出蛋白质消耗信号的假说提供了一些支持。