Bourdillon Nicolas, Schmitt Laurent, Yazdani Sasan, Vesin Jean-Marc, Millet Grégoire P
Faculty of Biology and Medicine, Institute of Sport Sciences, University of LausanneLausanne, Switzerland.
National Centre of Nordic-Ski, Research and PerformancePremanon, France.
Front Neurosci. 2017 Aug 10;11:456. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2017.00456. eCollection 2017.
Heart rate variability (HRV) is non-invasive and commonly used for monitoring responses to training loads, fitness, or overreaching in athletes. Yet, the recording duration for a series of RR-intervals varies from 1 to 15 min in the literature. The aim of the present work was to assess the minimum record duration to obtain reliable HRV results. RR-intervals from 159 orthostatic tests (7 min supine, SU, followed by 6 min standing, ST) were analyzed. Reference windows were 4 min in SU (min 3-7) and 4 min in ST (min 9-13). Those windows were subsequently divided and the analyses were repeated on eight different fractioned windows: the first min (0-1), the second min (1-2), the third min (2-3), the fourth min (3-4), the first 2 min (0-2), the last 2 min (2-4), the first 3 min (0-3), and the last 3 min (1-4). Correlation and Bland & Altman statistical analyses were systematically performed. The analysis window could be shortened to 0-2 instead of 0-4 for RMSSD only, whereas the 4-min window was necessary for LF and total power. Since there is a need for 1 min of baseline to obtain a steady signal prior the analysis window, we conclude that studies relying on RMSSD may shorten the windows to 3 min (= 1+2) in SU or seated position only and to 6 min (= 1+2 min SU plus 1+2 min ST) if there is an orthostatic test. Studies relying on time- and frequency-domain parameters need a minimum of 5 min (= 1+4) min SU or seated position only but require 10 min (= 1+4 min SU plus 1+4 min ST) for the orthostatic test.
心率变异性(HRV)是非侵入性的,常用于监测运动员对训练负荷、体能或过度训练的反应。然而,在文献中,一系列RR间期的记录时长从1分钟到15分钟不等。本研究的目的是评估获得可靠HRV结果所需的最短记录时长。分析了159次直立试验(7分钟仰卧,SU,随后6分钟站立,ST)的RR间期。参考窗口在SU时为4分钟(第3 - 7分钟),在ST时为4分钟(第9 - 13分钟)。随后将这些窗口进行划分,并在八个不同的分段窗口上重复分析:第1分钟(0 - 1)、第2分钟(1 - 2)、第3分钟(2 - 3)、第4分钟(3 - 4)、前2分钟(0 - 2)、后2分钟(2 - 4)、前3分钟(0 - 3)和后3分钟(1 - 4)。系统地进行了相关性分析以及布兰德-奥特曼统计分析。仅对于RMSSD,分析窗口可以缩短至0 - 2而非0 - 4,而对于低频功率和总功率,4分钟的窗口是必要的。由于在分析窗口之前需要1分钟的基线来获得稳定信号,我们得出结论,仅依赖RMSSD的研究在SU或仅坐姿时可将窗口缩短至3分钟(=1 + 2),如果进行直立试验则可缩短至6分钟(=1 + 2分钟SU加上1 + 2分钟ST)。依赖时域和频域参数的研究在仅SU或坐姿时至少需要5分钟(=1 + 4),但进行直立试验时需要10分钟(=1 + 4分钟SU加上1 + 4分钟ST)。