Maddineshat Maryam, Hashemi Mitra, Tabatabaeichehr Mahbubeh
Department of Nursing, Nursing and Midwifery Faculty, North Khorasn University of Medical sciences, Bojnurd, Iran.
Deputy of Research and Technology, North Khorasn University of Medical sciences, Bojnurd, Iran.
J Educ Health Promot. 2017 Aug 9;6:69. doi: 10.4103/jehp.jehp_47_16. eCollection 2017.
Understanding the development and distribution of disruptive behaviour among members of a health-care team is critical to the safety and quality of patient care in high-risk environments such as operating rooms. The present study identified disruptive behaviour and its effect on the treatment of patients in the operating room environment.
This cross-sectional study used the convenience sampling method to select 144 operating room physicians and nurses (91 women and 53 men). The study was conducted in the operating rooms of four academic hospitals with different specialties in North Khorasan province in Iran from December 2013 to September 2014. The data were collected using a translated, modified, and validated questionnaire to investigate the prevalence and consequences of disruptive behaviour, the response of the health care system to the behaviour, factors affecting the creation of conflict and the spread of disruptive behaviour. Statistical analysis of the data was performed using SPSS 18.
Disruptive behaviour was reported by 82.95% physicians and nurses. On average, 39% of physicians and 21% of operating room nurses exhibited disruptive behaviour. Disruptive behaviour is associated with psychological and clinical consequences. Factors such as fear of retaliation (8%), lack of change (43.8%), lack of security (18.1%) and attitude of the organization (14.6%) are significant reasons for the failure to report these behaviours.
The findings suggest that disruptive behaviour occurs and affects treatment and workflow of treatment teams in the operating room. Interpersonal conflict contributes to the growth of such behaviour; thus, more research should focus on this subject in the future.
了解医疗团队成员中破坏性行为的发展和分布情况,对于手术室等高风险环境下患者护理的安全和质量至关重要。本研究确定了破坏性行为及其对手术室环境中患者治疗的影响。
本横断面研究采用便利抽样法,选取了144名手术室医生和护士(91名女性和53名男性)。该研究于2013年12月至2014年9月在伊朗霍拉桑省北部四家不同专科的学术医院的手术室进行。使用一份经过翻译、修改和验证的问卷收集数据,以调查破坏性行为的发生率和后果、医疗系统对该行为的反应、影响冲突产生和破坏性行为传播的因素。使用SPSS 18对数据进行统计分析。
82.95%的医生和护士报告有破坏性行为。平均而言,39%的医生和21%的手术室护士表现出破坏性行为。破坏性行为与心理和临床后果相关。诸如害怕报复(8%)、缺乏改变(43.8%)、缺乏安全感(18.1%)和组织态度(14.6%)等因素是未报告这些行为的重要原因。
研究结果表明,破坏性行为在手术室中存在并影响治疗团队的治疗和工作流程。人际冲突助长了此类行为的滋生;因此,未来应更多地关注这一主题的研究。