Tolksdorf W, Krug C, Hartung M, Hettenbach A
Anasth Intensivther Notfallmed. 1987 Jun;22(3):113-7.
In 60 patients undergoing a curettage in thiopentone induced inhalation anaesthesia with enflurane and N2O/O2 = 2:1, the effects of oral premedication (2 h before anaesthesia) with 30 mg morphine (MST 30) (n = 21), 1 mg lormetazepam (Noctamid) (n = 19) and placebo (n = 21) on psychological (anxiety, depression and asthenia), physiological (blood pressure, heart and respiratory rate) and pain parameters (visual analogue scale, analgesic consumption) were investigated. The study design was single blind, randomized. Before premedication the three groups did not differ in one parameter and so were comparable. MST 30 had a significantly better anxiolytic, Lormetazepam a significantly better antidepressive effect than the compared substance. There were no differences in blood pressure and heart rate. In contrast to lormetazepam and placebo after MST 30 there was no increase in the respiratory rate which can be explained by the anxiolytic stress reducing effect. There was no difference in peri- and intraoperative pain parameters, probably due to the type of surgery. Nausea and vomiting occurred more frequently after MST 30, but there was no significance. A higher rate was probably prevented by the application of transdermal scopolamine the day before surgery. The indication of analgesics (opiates) for premedication is discussed taking the controversy into account. The results of this study show that oral morphine (MST 30) has an anxiolytic effect, one of the most important effects a premedication should have. Further studies should investigate in which types of surgery the analgesic effect of MST 30 is peri- and intraoperatively relevant, so that advantages compared to e.g. Flunitrazepam, Midazolam or Lormetazepam in a higher dosage could be expected.
在60例硫喷妥钠诱导吸入麻醉下行刮宫术的患者中,采用安氟醚及N2O/O2 = 2:1的麻醉方式,研究术前2小时口服30毫克吗啡(美施康定30)(n = 21)、1毫克氯羟安定(诺坦)(n = 19)及安慰剂(n = 21)对心理(焦虑、抑郁及乏力)、生理(血压、心率及呼吸频率)和疼痛参数(视觉模拟评分、镇痛药消耗量)的影响。研究设计为单盲、随机。术前用药前,三组在任何一项参数上均无差异,具有可比性。与对照药物相比,美施康定30具有显著更好的抗焦虑作用,氯羟安定具有显著更好的抗抑郁作用。血压和心率无差异。与氯羟安定和安慰剂不同,美施康定30用药后呼吸频率未增加,这可由其抗焦虑减轻应激作用来解释。围手术期和术中疼痛参数无差异,可能与手术类型有关。美施康定30用药后恶心和呕吐发生率更高,但无统计学意义。手术前一天应用透皮东莨菪碱可能预防了更高的发生率。考虑到存在的争议,讨论了术前用药使用镇痛药(阿片类)的指征。本研究结果表明,口服吗啡(美施康定30)具有抗焦虑作用,这是术前用药应具备的最重要作用之一。进一步研究应调查美施康定30的镇痛作用在哪些类型的手术中与围手术期和术中相关,以便预期与更高剂量的氟硝西泮、咪达唑仑或氯羟安定相比的优势。