Renieblas Gabriel Prieto, Nogués Agustín Turrero, González Alberto Muñoz, Gómez-Leon Nieves, Del Castillo Eduardo Guibelalde
Complutense University, Department of Radiology, Faculty of Medicine, Madrid, Spain.
Complutense University, Department of Statistics and Operations Research, Faculty of Medicine, Madrid, Spain.
J Med Imaging (Bellingham). 2017 Jul;4(3):035501. doi: 10.1117/1.JMI.4.3.035501. Epub 2017 Jul 26.
The structural similarity index (SSIM) family is a set of metrics that has demonstrated good agreement with human observers in tasks using reference images. These metrics analyze the viewing distance, edge information between the reference and the test images, changed and preserved edges, textures, and structural similarity of the images. Eight metrics based on that family are proposed. This new set of metrics, together with another eight well-known SSIM family metrics, was tested to predict human performance in some specific tasks closely related to the evaluation of radiological medical images. We used a database of radiological images, comprising different acquisition techniques (MRI and plain films). This database was distorted with different types of distortions (Gaussian blur, noise, etc.) and different levels of degradation. These images were analyzed by a board of radiologists with a double-stimulus methodology, and their results were compared with those obtained from the 16 metrics analyzed and proposed in this research. Our experimental results showed that the readings of human observers were sensitive to the changes and preservation of the edge information between the reference and test images, changes and preservation in the texture, structural component of the images, and simulation of multiple viewing distances. These results showed that several metrics that apply this multifactorial approach (4-G-SSIM, 4-MS-G-SSIM, [Formula: see text], and [Formula: see text]) can be used as good surrogates of a radiologist to analyze the medical quality of an image in an environment with a reference image.
结构相似性指数(SSIM)族是一组在使用参考图像的任务中已证明与人类观察者有良好一致性的度量标准。这些度量标准分析了观看距离、参考图像与测试图像之间的边缘信息、变化和保留的边缘、纹理以及图像的结构相似性。基于该族提出了八个度量标准。这组新的度量标准与另外八个著名的SSIM族度量标准一起,在一些与放射医学图像评估密切相关的特定任务中进行了测试,以预测人类的表现。我们使用了一个放射图像数据库,该数据库包含不同的采集技术(MRI和平片)。这个数据库受到了不同类型的失真(高斯模糊、噪声等)和不同程度的退化影响。这些图像由一组放射科医生采用双刺激方法进行分析,并将他们的结果与本研究中分析和提出的16个度量标准所获得的结果进行比较。我们的实验结果表明,人类观察者的读数对参考图像与测试图像之间边缘信息的变化和保留、纹理的变化和保留、图像的结构成分以及多种观看距离的模拟很敏感。这些结果表明,应用这种多因素方法的几个度量标准(4-G-SSIM、4-MS-G-SSIM、[公式:见原文]和[公式:见原文])可以作为放射科医生在有参考图像的环境中分析图像医学质量的良好替代指标。