Collins Rebecca L, Haas Ann, Haviland Amelia M, Elliott Marc N
*RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, CA †RAND Corporation ‡Carnegie Mellon University, H. John Heinz College of Public Policy and Management, Pittsburgh, PA.
Med Care. 2017 Nov;55(11):940-947. doi: 10.1097/MLR.0000000000000804.
Some aspects of patient experience are more strongly related to overall ratings of care than others, reflecting their importance to patients. However, little is known about whether the importance of different aspects of this experience differs across subgroups.
To determine whether the aspects of health care most important to patients differ according to patient race, ethnicity, and language preference.
In response to the 2013 Medicare Consumer Assessment of Health Plans Study (CAHPS) survey, patients rated their overall health care and completed items measuring five patient experience domains. We estimated a linear regression model to assess associations between overall rating of care and the 5 domains, testing for differences in these relationships for race/ethnicity/language groups, controlling for covariates.
In total 242,782 Medicare beneficiaries, age 65 years or older.
Overall rating of health care, composite patient experience scores for: doctor communication, getting needed care, getting care quickly, customer service, and care coordination.
A joint test of the interactions between the composite scores and the 5 largest racial/ethnic/language subgroups was statistically significant (P <0.0001), suggesting the importance of domains varied across subgroups. Doctor communication had the strongest relationship with care ratings for non-Hispanic whites and English-preferring Hispanics. Getting needed care had the strongest relationship for Spanish-preferring Hispanics and Asian/Pacific Islanders. Doctor communication and getting care quickly were strongest for African Americans.
Tailoring quality improvement programs to the factors most important to the racial, ethnic, and language mix of the patient population of the practice, hospital, or plan may more efficiently reduce disparities and improve quality.
患者体验的某些方面与整体护理评分的关联比其他方面更强,这反映了它们对患者的重要性。然而,对于这种体验的不同方面的重要性在不同亚组中是否存在差异,我们知之甚少。
确定对患者最重要的医疗保健方面是否因患者的种族、民族和语言偏好而异。
针对2013年医疗保险健康计划消费者评估(CAHPS)调查,患者对其整体医疗保健进行评分,并完成测量五个患者体验领域的项目。我们估计了一个线性回归模型,以评估护理总体评分与这五个领域之间的关联,检验种族/民族/语言组在这些关系上的差异,并控制协变量。
总共242,782名年龄在65岁及以上的医疗保险受益人。
医疗保健总体评分,以及以下方面的综合患者体验得分:医生沟通、获得所需护理、快速获得护理、客户服务和护理协调。
综合得分与五个最大的种族/民族/语言亚组之间的交互作用的联合检验具有统计学意义(P<0.0001),表明各领域的重要性在不同亚组中有所不同。对于非西班牙裔白人以及偏好英语的西班牙裔,医生沟通与护理评分的关系最为密切。对于偏好西班牙语的西班牙裔和亚太岛民,获得所需护理与护理评分的关系最为密切。对于非裔美国人,医生沟通和快速获得护理与护理评分的关系最为密切。
根据诊所、医院或计划中患者群体的种族、民族和语言构成,将质量改进计划针对最重要的因素进行调整,可能会更有效地减少差异并提高质量。