Department of Epidemiology and Preventive Medicine, School of Public Health and Preventive Medicine, Monash University, 553 St. Kilda Road, VIC 3004, Australia.
School of Medicine, Faculty of Health, Deakin University, Geelong 3216, Australia.
Health Policy Plan. 2017 Dec 1;32(10):1427-1436. doi: 10.1093/heapol/czx124.
Nepal introduced free delivery services for births in public facilities in 2005 in 25 districts with the intervention initially restricted to women with less than two living children and/or women with obstetric complications. After November 2007, eligibility conditions were relaxed to include all women, and the programme was later expanded to cover an additional 50 districts in December 2008. We exploit the phased expansion of the free birth delivery programme to identify its impact on place of delivery, the presence of skilled birth attendants (SBAs) and neonatal mortality using difference-in-difference methods, on data for 4457 live-births reported between 2001 and 2008 from Nepal Demographic and Health Surveys for 2006 and 2011. Programme impacts were estimated for: (1) initial implementation until the relaxation of eligibility criteria to include all women in November 2007 (early phase); and (2) initial implementation until the programme was expanded nationwide in December 2008 (longer phase). Early implementing districts were treatment districts, while late implementing hill districts were control districts. In the early phase, the likelihood of delivery by SBAs was 5.6 percentage points higher (95%CI 0.002, 0.111) and the likelihood of delivery in a public facility was 5.1 percentage points higher (95%CI -0.003, 0.106) in treatment districts compared with control districts. The programme lowered the likelihood of neonatal mortality by 4.0 (-0.072, -0.009) percentage points for women with less than two living children and by 6.9 percentage points (95%CI -0.104, -0.035) for women from lower castes and indigenous groups in treatment districts compared with women in control districts, during the early phase. Programme effects on use of public facilities for births and deliveries attended by SBAs were not sustained over a longer exposure period. The results on neonatal mortality persisted with longer programme exposure, although the effects were smaller in magnitude.
尼泊尔于 2005 年在 25 个地区推出了免费分娩服务,最初的干预措施仅限于生育不足两个存活子女的妇女和/或有产科并发症的妇女。2007 年 11 月之后,资格条件放宽到包括所有妇女,随后该方案于 2008 年 12 月进一步扩大到另外 50 个地区。我们利用免费分娩方案的分阶段扩大,利用差异法,根据尼泊尔 2001 年至 2008 年期间进行的 2006 年和 2011 年的四次人口与健康调查的 4457 例活产数据,来确定其对分娩地点、熟练接生员(SBA)的存在和新生儿死亡率的影响。方案影响估计包括:(1)从 2007 年 11 月放宽资格标准,包括所有妇女之前的初始实施阶段(早期阶段);(2)从 2008 年 12 月方案在全国范围内扩大之前的初始实施阶段(较长阶段)。早期实施地区为治疗区,而后期实施的丘陵地区为对照区。在早期阶段,与对照区相比,治疗区由 SBA 接生的可能性高 5.6 个百分点(95%CI 0.002,0.111),在公共设施分娩的可能性高 5.1 个百分点(95%CI -0.003,0.106)。与对照区的妇女相比,该方案降低了低种姓和土著群体中生育不足两个存活子女的妇女的新生儿死亡率 4.0 个百分点(95%CI -0.072,-0.009),降低了 6.9 个百分点(95%CI -0.104,-0.035)。在早期阶段,治疗区由 SBA 接生的公共设施分娩和接生的比例没有随着更长的暴露期而持续。随着更长时间的方案暴露,新生儿死亡率的结果持续存在,尽管影响的幅度较小。