Holroyd-Leduc Jayna, Resin Joyce, Ashley Lisa, Barwich Doris, Elliott Jacobi, Huras Paul, Légaré France, Mahoney Megan, Maybee Alies, McNeil Heather, Pullman Daryl, Sawatzky Richard, Stolee Paul, Muscedere John
Department of Medicine and Community Health Services, University of Calgary, Calgary, AB Canada.
Canadian Frailty Network, Vancouver, BC Canada.
Res Involv Engagem. 2016 Jun 17;2:23. doi: 10.1186/s40900-016-0038-7. eCollection 2016.
The paper discusses engaging older adults living with frailty their family caregivers. Frailty is a state that puts an individual at a higher risk for poor health outcomes and death. Understanding whether a person is frail is important because treatment and health care choices for someone living with frailty may be different from someone who is not (i.e., who is fit). In this review, we discuss strategies and hurdles for engaging older adults living with frailty across three settings: research, health and social care, and policy. We developed this review using published literature, expert opinion, and stakeholder input (including citizens). Engaging frail older individuals will be challenging because of their vulnerable health state - but it can be done. Points of consideration specific to engaging this vulnerable population include:In any setting, family caregivers (defined to include family, friends, and other social support systems) play an important role in engaging and empowering older adults living with frailtyEngagement opportunities need to be flexible (e.g., location, time, type)Incentivizing engagement for researchers and citizens (financial and otherwise) may be necessaryThe education and training of citizens, health and social care providers, and researchers on engagement practicesPatient-centered care approaches should consider the specific needs of individuals living with frailty including end-of-life care and advanced care planningInfluencing policy can occur in many ways including participating at institutional, regional, provincial or national committees that relate to health and social care.
Older adults are the fastest growing segment of Canada's population resulting in an increased number of individuals living with frailty. Although aging and frailty are not synonymous the proportion of those who are frail increases with age. Frailty is not defined by a single condition, but rather a health state characterized by an increased risk of physical, mental, or social decline, deterioration of health status, and death. Recognizing frailty is important because earlier detection allows for program implementation focused on prevention and management to reduce future hospitalization, improve outcomes, and enhance vitality and quality of life. Even though older adults living with frailty are significant users of health care resources, their input is under-represented in research, health care decision making, and health policy formulation. As such, engaging older adults living with frailty and their family caregivers is not only an ethical imperative, but their input is particularly important as health and social care systems evolve from single-illness focused to those that account for the complex and chronic needs that accompany frailty. In this review, we summarize existing literature on engaging older adults living with frailty and their family caregivers across three settings: research, health and social care, and policy. We discuss strategies and barriers to engagement, and ethical and cultural factors and implications. Although this review is mainly focused on Canada it is likely to be broadly applicable to many of the health systems in the developed world where aging and frailty pose important challenges.
本文讨论了让体弱的老年人及其家庭护理人员参与进来的问题。体弱是一种使个体面临健康状况不佳和死亡风险更高的状态。了解一个人是否体弱很重要,因为体弱老人的治疗和医疗保健选择可能与非体弱(即健康)的人不同。在本综述中,我们讨论了在研究、卫生和社会护理以及政策这三个领域让体弱老年人参与进来的策略和障碍。我们利用已发表的文献、专家意见和利益相关者(包括公民)的意见编写了本综述。让体弱的老年人参与进来具有挑战性,因为他们的健康状况脆弱——但这是可以做到的。针对让这一弱势群体参与进来的具体考虑因素包括:
在任何领域,家庭护理人员(定义包括家人、朋友和其他社会支持系统)在让体弱老年人参与并赋予其权力方面发挥着重要作用
参与机会需要灵活(例如地点、时间、类型)
可能有必要激励研究人员和公民参与(经济及其他方面)
对公民、卫生和社会护理提供者以及研究人员进行参与实践方面的教育和培训
以患者为中心的护理方法应考虑体弱老年人的特殊需求,包括临终护理和高级护理规划
影响政策可以通过多种方式实现,包括参与与卫生和社会护理相关的机构、地区、省级或国家级委员会。
老年人是加拿大人口中增长最快的群体,导致体弱的人数增加。虽然衰老和体弱不是同义词,但体弱的比例会随着年龄增长而增加。体弱并非由单一状况定义,而是一种以身体、心理或社会衰退、健康状况恶化以及死亡风险增加为特征的健康状态。认识到体弱很重要,因为早期发现有助于实施侧重于预防和管理的项目,以减少未来的住院次数、改善结果并提高活力和生活质量。尽管体弱的老年人是医疗保健资源的重要使用者,但他们在研究、医疗保健决策和卫生政策制定中的意见却未得到充分体现。因此,让体弱的老年人及其家庭护理人员参与进来不仅是一项道德要求,而且随着卫生和社会护理系统从专注单一疾病转向满足体弱所伴随的复杂和慢性需求,他们的意见尤为重要。在本综述中,我们总结了关于在研究、卫生和社会护理以及政策这三个领域让体弱的老年人及其家庭护理人员参与进来的现有文献。我们讨论了参与的策略和障碍以及伦理和文化因素及影响。尽管本综述主要聚焦于加拿大,但它可能广泛适用于发达国家的许多卫生系统,在这些国家,老龄化和体弱构成了重大挑战。