Independent Consultant, Brussels, Belgium.
University of Applied Sciences, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Matern Child Nutr. 2018 Apr;14(2):e12551. doi: 10.1111/mcn.12551. Epub 2017 Oct 24.
Child malnutrition remains high in Ethiopia, and inadequate complementary feeding is a contributing factor. In this context, a community-based intervention was designed to provide locally made complementary food for children 6-23 months, using a bartering system, in four Ethiopian regions. After a pilot phase, the intervention was scaled up from 8 to 180 localities. We conducted a process evaluation to determine enablers and barriers for the scaling up of this intervention. Eight study sites were selected to perform 52 key informant interviews and 31 focus group discussions with purposely selected informants. For analysis, we used a framework describing six elements of successful scaling up: socio-political context, attributes of the intervention, attributes of the implementers, appropriate delivery strategy, the adopting community, and use of research to inform the scale-up process. A strong political will, alignment of the intervention with national priorities, and integration with the health care system were instrumental in the scaling up. The participatory approach in decision-making reinforced ownership at community level, and training about complementary feeding motivated mothers and women's groups to participate. However, the management of the complex intervention, limited human resources, and lack of incentives for female volunteers proved challenging. In the bartering model, the barter rate was accepted, but the bartering was hindered by unavailability of cereals and limited financial and material resources to contribute, threatening the project's sustainability. Scaling up strategies for nutrition interventions require sufficient time, thorough planning, and assessment of the community's capacity to contribute human, financial, and material resources.
儿童营养不良在埃塞俄比亚仍然很严重,而补充喂养不足是一个促成因素。在这种情况下,设计了一项基于社区的干预措施,以物物交换的方式为 6-23 个月大的儿童提供当地制作的补充食品,该干预措施在埃塞俄比亚的四个地区进行。在试点阶段之后,该干预措施从 8 个地点扩大到 180 个地点。我们进行了一项过程评估,以确定扩大该干预措施的促成因素和障碍。选择了 8 个研究地点,对精心挑选的知情人进行了 52 次关键知情人访谈和 31 次焦点小组讨论。为了进行分析,我们使用了一个描述成功扩大规模的六个要素的框架:社会政治背景、干预措施的属性、实施者的属性、适当的交付策略、采用社区以及利用研究为扩大规模过程提供信息。强烈的政治意愿、干预措施与国家优先事项的一致性以及与医疗保健系统的整合,是扩大规模的关键因素。参与式决策方法加强了社区一级的所有权,补充喂养方面的培训激励了母亲和妇女团体参与。然而,复杂干预措施的管理、人力资源有限以及对女性志愿者缺乏激励,都给项目的可持续性带来了挑战。在物物交换模式中,物物交换率得到了接受,但由于谷物短缺以及用于贡献人力、财务和物质资源的有限资源,物物交换受到阻碍,威胁到项目的可持续性。营养干预措施的扩大策略需要足够的时间、全面的规划以及对社区贡献人力、财务和物质资源的能力进行评估。