Kleszczewska Dorota, Dzielska Anna, Nałęcz Hanna, Mazur Joanna
Foundation of the Institute of Mother and Child.
Department of Child and Adolescent Health, Institute of Mother and Child, Warsaw, Poland.
Dev Period Med. 2017;21(3):235-247. doi: 10.34763/devperiodmed.20172103.235247.
The wrong subjective assessment of body mass may have consequences for the health, quality of life and proper functioning of adolescents in society.
The purpose of the study is to provide a detailed analysis of the discrepancies between the objective and subjective assessment of body mass by 15-year-old boys and girls in Poland against the background of international statistics and to assess the effect of physical activity on the level and directions of these discrepancies.
The data concerned 72037 schoolchildren from 42 countries, including 1484 in Poland. The measure of objective body mass was the BMI categorized according to Cole's criteria. Research focused on the relation between the mean BMI and the subjective perception of their body mass by adolescents and the discrepancy in this assessment. In addition, the level of physical activity (MVPA) was taken into account.
In Poland the percentage of adolescents with overweight was lower than the international average and amounted to 12.3% vs. 15.2%. The percentage of 15-year-old boys with overweight in Poland is nearly three times higher than girls of the same age (18.7% vs. 6.5%) and is at the mean level for Health Behaviour in School-aged Children (HBSC) countries. According to international statistics, the percentage of adolescents who consider themselves overweight is 32.7%, which is two times higher than the percentage of actual excess body weight. Polish girls are systematically first in the ranking of those who consider themselves too fat. It was demonstrated that Polish girls with a normal BMI for their age who consider themselves too fat are on average slimmer than their peers in other countries. There is a correlation between Moderate-to-Vigorous Physical Activity (MVPA) and the accuracy of self-assessment of body mass and the type of mistakes made in that assessment, which is more clearly marked among boys.
There are clear geographical and cultural differences in the level of discrepancies between the objective and subjective assessment of body mass among teenagers. Physical activity modifies these discrepancies.
对体重的错误主观评估可能会对青少年的健康、生活质量以及在社会中的正常功能产生影响。
本研究的目的是在国际统计数据的背景下,详细分析波兰15岁男孩和女孩在体重客观评估与主观评估之间的差异,并评估体育活动对这些差异的程度和方向的影响。
数据涉及来自42个国家的72037名学童,其中包括波兰的1484名。客观体重的衡量指标是根据科尔标准分类的体重指数(BMI)。研究重点关注平均BMI与青少年对自己体重的主观认知之间的关系以及这种评估中的差异。此外,还考虑了体育活动水平(中等至剧烈身体活动,MVPA)。
在波兰,超重青少年的比例低于国际平均水平,分别为12.3%和15.2%。波兰15岁超重男孩的比例几乎是同龄女孩的三倍(18.7%对6.5%),处于学龄儿童健康行为(HBSC)国家的平均水平。根据国际统计数据,认为自己超重的青少年比例为32.7%,这比实际超重的比例高出两倍。波兰女孩在认为自己太胖的人群排名中系统性地位居榜首。结果表明,波兰那些认为自己太胖但BMI正常的同龄女孩平均比其他国家的同龄人更瘦。中等至剧烈身体活动(MVPA)与体重自我评估的准确性以及该评估中所犯错误的类型之间存在相关性,在男孩中这种相关性更为明显。
青少年在体重客观评估与主观评估之间的差异水平存在明显的地理和文化差异。体育活动会改变这些差异。