Namasivayam-MacDonald Ashwini M, Barbon Carly E A, Steele Catriona M
Swallowing Rehabilitation Research Laboratory, Toronto Rehabilitation Institute - University Health Network, Toronto, Canada; Adelphi University, Garden City, NY, USA.
Swallowing Rehabilitation Research Laboratory, Toronto Rehabilitation Institute - University Health Network, Toronto, Canada; Rehabilitation Sciences Institute, Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Physiol Behav. 2018 Feb 1;184:12-26. doi: 10.1016/j.physbeh.2017.10.023. Epub 2017 Oct 27.
Many studies evaluate dysphagia in elderly patients and compare their swallowing to younger controls to assess the degree of swallowing impairment. Previous research suggests that changes should be expected in swallowing due to aging, and these changes need to be considered when performing swallowing assessments. A systematic review was conducted to elucidate the timing of swallowing in healthy. A comprehensive multiengine literature search was conducted to find articles studying swallowing in the healthy elderly, which yielded 22,852 articles of which 11 were judged to be relevant. Only articles using videofluoroscopy as an assessment method for swallowing timing were included. The articles underwent detailed review for study quality and data extraction. The eleven studies contained data for 32 different parameters, and 10 of the 11 studies compared elderly subjects to a younger group. Timing measures from the studies were compiled for analysis. In general, bolus transit times do not appear to change with age. Of note, elderly subjects tended to have a significantly delayed swallow response times and longer duration of upper esophageal sphincter opening. Results showed a large degree of variability across studies for each of the timing measures. Confidence intervals for timing in healthy older participants were computed across studies. Potential sources of variation were identified, including methodological, stimulus-related and participant-related sources. The results suggests that aging affects only a few very specific swallowing timing parameters, and many parameters appear to be unaffected by aging. Therefore, significant differences from a young reference sample should be interpreted as dysphagia rather than normal changes due to aging.
许多研究对老年患者的吞咽困难进行评估,并将他们的吞咽情况与年轻对照组进行比较,以评估吞咽功能受损的程度。先前的研究表明,由于衰老,吞咽功能会发生变化,在进行吞咽评估时需要考虑这些变化。为了阐明健康人群吞咽的时间规律,我们进行了一项系统综述。我们进行了全面的多引擎文献检索,以查找研究健康老年人吞咽情况的文章,共检索到22,852篇文章,其中11篇被判定为相关。仅纳入了使用视频荧光吞咽造影作为吞咽时间评估方法的文章。对这些文章进行了详细的研究质量审查和数据提取。这11项研究包含了32个不同参数的数据,其中11项研究中有10项将老年受试者与年轻组进行了比较。对研究中的时间测量数据进行了汇总分析。一般来说,食团通过时间似乎不会随年龄变化。值得注意的是,老年受试者的吞咽反应时间往往明显延迟,食管上括约肌开放时间更长。结果显示,各项时间测量在不同研究间存在很大差异。计算了健康老年参与者吞咽时间的研究间置信区间。确定了潜在的变异来源,包括方法学、刺激相关和参与者相关的来源。结果表明,衰老仅影响少数非常特定的吞咽时间参数,许多参数似乎不受衰老影响。因此,与年轻参考样本的显著差异应被解释为吞咽困难,而非衰老导致的正常变化。