Department of Community Health Sciences, The Aga Khan University, Stadium Road, Karachi, 74800, Pakistan.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2017 Nov 7;17(1):704. doi: 10.1186/s12913-017-2664-7.
From 1990 to 2015, the number of maternal deaths globally has dropped by 43%. Despite this, progress in attaining MDG 5 is not remarkable in LMICs. Only 52% of pregnant women in LMICs obtain WHO recommended minimum of four antenatal consultations and the coverage of postnatal care is relatively poor. In recent years, the increased cellphone penetration has brought the potential for mHealth to improve preventive maternal healthcare services. The objective of this review is to assess the effectiveness of mHealth solutions on a range of maternal health outcomes by categorizing the interventions according to the types of mHealth applications.
Three international online electronic databases were searched between January 1, 2000 and January 25, 2016 to identify studies exploring the role of mHealth solutions in improving preventive maternal healthcare services. Of 1262 titles screened after duplication, 69 potentially relevant abstracts were obtained. Out of 69 abstracts, 42 abstracts were shortlisted. Full text of 42 articles was reviewed using data extraction sheet. A total of 14 full text studies were included in the final analysis.
The 14 final studies were categorized in to five mHealth applications defined in the conceptual framework. Based on our analysis, the most reported use of mHealth was for client education and behavior change communication, such as SMS and voice reminders [n = 9, 65%]. The categorization provided the understanding that much work have been done on client education and behavior change communication. Most of the studies showed that mHealth interventions have proven to be effective to improve antenatal care and postnatal care services, especially those that are aimed at changing behavior of pregnant women and women in postnatal period. However, little evidence exists on other type of mHealth applications.
This review suggests that mHealth solutions targeted at pregnant women and women in postnatal period can improve preventive maternal healthcare services. However, there is a need to conduct more controlled-trials and quasi-experimental studies to strengthen the literature in this research area. The review recommends that mHealth researchers, sponsors, and publishers should prioritize the transparent reporting of interventions to allow effective interpretation of extracted data.
从 1990 年到 2015 年,全球孕产妇死亡人数下降了 43%。尽管如此,在中低收入国家,实现千年发展目标 5 的进展并不显著。中低收入国家只有 52%的孕妇接受了世卫组织建议的至少四次产前检查,而且产后护理的覆盖率相对较差。近年来,手机普及率的提高为移动医疗改善预防孕产妇保健服务带来了潜力。本综述的目的是通过根据移动医疗应用的类型对干预措施进行分类,评估移动医疗解决方案在一系列孕产妇健康结果上的效果。
在 2000 年 1 月 1 日至 2016 年 1 月 25 日期间,在三个国际在线电子数据库中搜索了探索移动医疗解决方案在改善预防孕产妇保健服务中的作用的研究。在重复后的 1262 个标题中,有 69 个可能相关的摘要。在 69 个摘要中,有 42 个摘要被列为候选。使用数据提取表对 42 篇全文文章进行了综述。共有 14 项全文研究被纳入最终分析。
这 14 项最终研究被归入概念框架中定义的五个移动医疗应用类别。根据我们的分析,移动医疗应用最常见的用途是客户教育和行为改变沟通,如短信和语音提醒[9 项,占 65%]。这种分类使我们了解到,在客户教育和行为改变沟通方面已经做了很多工作。大多数研究表明,移动医疗干预措施已被证明可以有效改善产前护理和产后护理服务,特别是那些旨在改变孕妇和产后妇女行为的干预措施。然而,关于其他类型的移动医疗应用的证据很少。
本综述表明,针对孕妇和产后妇女的移动医疗解决方案可以改善预防孕产妇保健服务。然而,需要进行更多的对照试验和准实验研究,以加强这一研究领域的文献。本综述建议移动医疗研究人员、赞助者和出版商应优先透明报告干预措施,以便对提取的数据进行有效解释。