Ahmed Mansoor, Hwang Jung Hye, Choi Soojeung, Han Dongwoon
Department of Global Health and Development & Department of Preventive Medicine, Hanyang University, College of Medicine, 222 Wangsimni-ro, Seongdong-gu, Seoul, 04763, South Korea.
Institute of Health Services Management, Seoul, South Korea.
BMC Complement Altern Med. 2017 Nov 14;17(1):489. doi: 10.1186/s12906-017-1995-6.
High prevalence of herbal medicines used in pregnancy and the lack of information on their safety is a public concern. Despite this, no significant research has been done regarding potential adverse effects of using herbal medicines during pregnancy, especially among developing Asian countries.
Cross-sectional studies were searched up to year 2016 on PubMed/Medline and EMBASE, the data were extracted and quality of studies was assessed using the quality appraisal tool. The findings are reported in accordance to the PRISMA checklist (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses). Classification on safety of identified herbal medicines was done based on current scientific literature.
This study included eight cross-sectional studies (2729 participants) from seven different Asian countries, of which 1283 (47.01%) women used one or more herbal medicines during pregnancy. Peppermint (22.8%), aniseed (14.7%), olibanum (12.9%), flixweed seed (12.2%) and ginger (11.5%) were the most frequently used herbal medicines. Out of the 33 identified herbal medicines, 13 were classified as safe to use, five as use with caution, eight were potentially harmful to use in pregnancy and information on seven herbal medicines was not available in the current literature.
Several herbal medicines identified in this review were classified to be potentially harmful or the information regarding safety in pregnancy was missing. It is recommended that contraindicated herbal medicines should be avoided and other herbals should be taken under supervision of a qualified health care practitioner. The classification regarding safety of herbal medicines in pregnancy can be utilized to create awareness on prevention of adverse effects.
孕期使用草药的高发生率及其安全性信息的缺乏是一个公众关注的问题。尽管如此,关于孕期使用草药的潜在不良影响,尤其是在亚洲发展中国家,尚未开展重大研究。
检索截至2016年PubMed/Medline和EMBASE上的横断面研究,提取数据并使用质量评估工具评估研究质量。研究结果按照PRISMA清单(系统评价和Meta分析的首选报告项目)进行报告。根据当前科学文献对已识别草药的安全性进行分类。
本研究纳入了来自七个不同亚洲国家的八项横断面研究(2729名参与者),其中1283名(47.01%)女性在孕期使用了一种或多种草药。薄荷(22.8%)、茴芹籽(14.7%)、乳香(12.9%)、播娘蒿籽(12.2%)和生姜(11.5%)是最常使用的草药。在已识别的33种草药中,13种被分类为使用安全,5种需谨慎使用,8种在孕期使用可能有害,目前文献中没有关于7种草药的安全性信息。
本综述中识别出的几种草药被分类为可能有害或缺乏孕期安全性信息。建议避免使用禁忌草药,其他草药应在合格医疗保健从业者的监督下服用。孕期草药安全性分类可用于提高对预防不良反应的认识。