Dona Olga, Hall Geoffrey B, Noseworthy Michael D
McMaster School of Biomedical Engineering, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
Imaging Research Centre, St. Joseph's Healthcare, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
PLoS One. 2017 Dec 22;12(12):e0190081. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0190081. eCollection 2017.
Brain connectivity in autism spectrum disorders (ASD) has proven difficult to characterize due to the heterogeneous nature of the spectrum. Connectivity in the brain occurs in a complex, multilevel and multi-temporal manner, driving the fluctuations observed in local oxygen demand. These fluctuations can be characterized as fractals, as they auto-correlate at different time scales. In this study, we propose a model-free complexity analysis based on the fractal dimension of the rs-BOLD signal, acquired with magnetic resonance imaging. The fractal dimension can be interpreted as measure of signal complexity and connectivity. Previous studies have suggested that reduction in signal complexity can be associated with disease. Therefore, we hypothesized that a detectable difference in rs-BOLD signal complexity could be observed between ASD patients and Controls.
Anatomical and functional data from fifty-five subjects with ASD (12.7 ± 2.4 y/o) and 55 age-matched (14.1 ± 3.1 y/o) healthy controls were accessed through the NITRC database and the ABIDE project. Subjects were scanned using a 3T GE Signa MRI and a 32-channel RF-coil. Axial FSPGR-3D images were used to prescribe rs-BOLD (TE/TR = 30/2000ms) where 300 time points were acquired. Motion correction was performed on the functional data and anatomical and functional images were aligned and spatially warped to the N27 standard brain atlas. Fractal analysis, performed on a grey matter mask, was done by estimating the Hurst exponent in the frequency domain using a power spectral density approach and refining the estimation in the time domain with de-trended fluctuation analysis and signal summation conversion methods. Voxel-wise fractal dimension (FD) was calculated for every subject in the control group and in the ASD group to create ROI-based Z-scores for the ASD patients. Voxel-wise validation of FD normality across controls was confirmed, and non-Gaussian voxels were eliminated from subsequent analysis. To maintain a 95% confidence level, only regions where Z-score values were at least 2 standard deviations away from the mean (i.e. where |Z| > 2.0) were included in the analysis. We found that the main regions, where signal complexity significantly decreased among ASD patients, were the amygdala (p = 0.001), the vermis (p = 0.02), the basal ganglia (p = 0.01) and the hippocampus (p = 0.02). No regions reported significant increase in signal complexity in this study. Our findings were correlated with ADIR and ADOS assessment tools, reporting the highest correlation with the ADOS metrics.
Brain connectivity is best modeled as a complex system. Therefore, a measure of complexity as the fractal dimension of fluctuations in brain oxygen demand and utilization could provide important information about connectivity issues in ASD. Moreover, this technique can be used in the characterization of a single subject, with respect to controls, without the need for group analysis. Our novel approach provides an ideal avenue for personalized diagnostics, thus providing unique patient specific assessment that could help in individualizing treatments.
由于自闭症谱系障碍(ASD)谱系的异质性,其大脑连接性已被证明难以表征。大脑中的连接以复杂、多层面和多时间尺度的方式发生,驱动着局部氧需求中观察到的波动。这些波动可被表征为分形,因为它们在不同时间尺度上自相关。在本研究中,我们提出了一种基于磁共振成像获取的静息态功能磁共振成像(rs-BOLD)信号分形维数的无模型复杂性分析方法。分形维数可被解释为信号复杂性和连接性的度量。先前的研究表明,信号复杂性的降低可能与疾病有关。因此,我们假设在ASD患者和对照组之间可以观察到rs-BOLD信号复杂性的可检测差异。
通过NITRC数据库和ABIDE项目获取了55名ASD受试者(12.7±2.4岁)和55名年龄匹配(14.1±3.1岁)的健康对照的解剖和功能数据。受试者使用3T GE Signa MRI和32通道射频线圈进行扫描。轴向扰相梯度回波三维(FSPGR-3D)图像用于定位rs-BOLD(回波时间/重复时间=30/2000毫秒),采集300个时间点。对功能数据进行运动校正,并将解剖和功能图像对齐并空间扭曲到N27标准脑图谱。在灰质掩膜上进行分形分析,通过使用功率谱密度方法在频域中估计赫斯特指数,并使用去趋势波动分析和信号求和转换方法在时域中细化估计。为对照组和ASD组的每个受试者计算体素级分形维数(FD),以创建基于感兴趣区域(ROI)的ASD患者Z分数。确认了对照组FD正态性的体素级验证,并从后续分析中排除非高斯体素。为保持95%的置信水平,分析仅包括Z分数值至少比平均值偏离2个标准差(即|Z|>2.0)的区域。我们发现,ASD患者中信号复杂性显著降低的主要区域是杏仁核(p=0.001)、小脑蚓部(p=0.02)、基底神经节(p=0.01)和海马体(p=0.02)。本研究中没有区域报告信号复杂性显著增加。我们的发现与自闭症诊断访谈修订版(ADIR)和自闭症诊断观察量表(ADOS)评估工具相关,与ADOS指标的相关性最高。
大脑连接性最好被建模为一个复杂系统。因此,将复杂性度量为大脑氧需求和利用波动的分形维数,可以提供有关ASD连接性问题的重要信息。此外,该技术可用于单个受试者相对于对照组的表征,而无需进行组分析。我们的新方法为个性化诊断提供了理想途径,从而提供独特的患者特异性评估,有助于实现个体化治疗。