Boschman Sanne, Kleinhans Reinout, van Ham Maarten
Department of Sociology/ICS, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Department OTB - Research for the Built Environment, Faculty of Architecture and the Built Environment, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands.
J Hous Built Environ. 2017;32(3):495-512. doi: 10.1007/s10901-016-9524-3. Epub 2016 Aug 9.
Selective mobility into and out of urban neighbourhoods is one of the main driving forces of segregation. Earlier research has found group differences in who wants to leave or who leaves certain types of neighbourhoods. A factor that has received little attention so far is that some residents will have a desire to leave their neighbourhood, but are unable to do so. If there are differences between population groups in the realisation of desires to leave the neighbourhood, this might lead to involuntary segregation. This paper uses a unique combination of register data and survey data. We combine data from a large housing survey in the Netherlands (WoON) with longitudinal register data from the Netherlands (SSD) which contains individual-level information on residential mobility histories. This allows us to study whether households with a desire to leave their neighbourhood do realise this desire and which households are successful in leaving which neighbourhoods. A more thorough insight in who wants to leave which neighbourhoods but is unable to do so will contribute to a better understanding of selective mobility and segregation. We find that ethnic minorities and low-income households are less likely to realise a desire to leave their neighbourhood. We expected that ethnic minorities would be especially unsuccessful in realising desires to leave minority concentration neighbourhoods; however, for none of the ethnic groups we found an effect of neighbourhood ethnic composition on the realisation of desires to leave.
城市社区之间的选择性流动是隔离的主要驱动力之一。早期研究发现,在谁想离开或谁离开了某些类型社区的问题上存在群体差异。一个迄今为止很少受到关注的因素是,一些居民虽然有离开社区的愿望,但却无法做到。如果不同人群在实现离开社区愿望方面存在差异,这可能会导致非自愿隔离。本文使用了登记数据和调查数据的独特组合。我们将荷兰一项大型住房调查(WoON)的数据与荷兰的纵向登记数据(SSD)相结合,后者包含了关于居住流动历史的个人层面信息。这使我们能够研究那些有离开社区愿望的家庭是否实现了这一愿望,以及哪些家庭成功离开了哪些社区。更深入地了解谁想离开哪个社区但却无法做到,将有助于更好地理解选择性流动和隔离。我们发现,少数族裔和低收入家庭实现离开社区愿望的可能性较小。我们原本预计少数族裔在实现离开少数族裔集中社区的愿望方面会特别不成功;然而,对于任何一个族裔群体,我们都没有发现社区种族构成对实现离开愿望有影响。