Yarnold John
1 Division of Radiotherapy and Imaging, The Institute of Cancer Research , London , UK.
Br J Radiol. 2019 Jan;92(1093):20170849. doi: 10.1259/bjr.20170849. Epub 2018 Mar 19.
Conventional fractionation for half a century has been justified on the basis that 2.0 Gy fractions spare dose-limiting late-responding normal tissues to a greater degree than cancerous tissues. Early indications that breast cancer responds more strongly to fraction size than many other common cancers were followed several decades of investigation, but there is now reliable Level I evidence that this is the case. Four randomised trials testing fraction sizes in the range 2.7-3.3 Gy have reported 10-year follow up in almost 8000 patients, and they provide robust estimates of α/β in the range of 3 Gy. The implication is that there are no advantages in terms of safety or effectiveness of persisting with 2.0 Gy fractions in patients with breast cancer. 15- or 16-fraction schedules are replacing the conventional 25-fraction regimen as a standard of care for adjuvant therapy in an increasing number of countries. A number of concerns relating to the appropriateness of hypofractionation in patient subgroups, including those treated post-mastectomy, advanced local-regional disease and/or to lymphatic pathways are addressed. Meanwhile, hypofractionation can be exploited to modulate dose intensity across the breast according to relapse risk by varying fraction size across the treatment volume. The lower limits of hypofractionation are currently being explored, one approach testing a 5-fraction schedule of local-regional radiotherapy delivered in 1 week.
半个世纪以来,传统分割放疗的合理性在于,2.0Gy的分割剂量比癌组织能更大程度地保护剂量限制晚期反应正常组织。早期迹象表明,乳腺癌对分割剂量的反应比许多其他常见癌症更为强烈,随后经过了数十年的研究,现在有可靠的一级证据证明确实如此。四项测试2.7 - 3.3Gy分割剂量的随机试验报告了近8000名患者的10年随访结果,这些结果提供了α/β在3Gy范围内的可靠估计。这意味着对于乳腺癌患者,坚持使用2.0Gy分割剂量在安全性或有效性方面并无优势。在越来越多的国家,15或16分割方案正在取代传统的25分割方案,成为辅助治疗的标准治疗方案。文中还讨论了与部分患者亚组(包括乳房切除术后患者、局部区域晚期疾病患者和/或有淋巴转移途径的患者)中低分割放疗的适宜性相关的一些问题。同时,低分割放疗可通过在治疗体积内改变分割剂量大小,根据复发风险调整全乳的剂量强度。目前正在探索低分割放疗的下限,一种方法是测试在1周内进行5分割的局部区域放疗方案。