Institute of Agricultural Sciences, ETH Zurich, Universitaetstrasse 2 - 8092 Zurich, Switzerland.
Institute for Environmental Decisions, Consumer Behavior, ETH Zurich, Universitaetstrasse 22 - 8092 Zurich, Switzerland.
Poult Sci. 2018 Mar 1;97(3):1089-1098. doi: 10.3382/ps/pex397.
Chick culling is an efficient and cost-effective method in modern poultry farming, but it raises ethical concerns. Dual-purpose poultry (DP), in which males are fattened and females are used for egg production, is currently the most realistic alternative to culling, as in ovo sexing is not yet viable for practical application. Consumers' acceptance of DP products and their willingness to pay (WTP) for them have not been studied yet, and we expect that both aspects are closely related to the acceptance of and WTP for products from systems claiming beyond-conventional animal welfare, such as organic products. Results from a survey conducted among 402 consumers at 8 Swiss supermarkets revealed that the practice of chick culling was largely unknown (75% of respondents). Generally, respondents' knowledge about poultry production was low. The DP alternative was preferred to chick culling, but no preference emerged between DP and in ovo sexing. Furthermore, the WTP for DP products was proportionally lower for chicken than for eggs, probably because of the different price elasticity between these products. A regression analysis was used to determine the factors influencing consumers' WTP for DP products. Consumers' WTP was positively related to knowledge about poultry production, habits tied to purchasing organic or free-range poultry products, and familiarity with DP products. Therefore, a combination of the DP alternative with an organic label is recommended.
淘汰雏鸡是现代家禽养殖中一种高效且具有成本效益的方法,但它引发了伦理问题。兼用型家禽(DP),即雄性家禽用于育肥,雌性家禽用于产蛋,目前是淘汰雏鸡的最现实替代品,因为种蛋性别鉴定尚未可行实际应用。消费者对 DP 产品的接受程度及其支付意愿(WTP)尚未得到研究,我们预计这两个方面都与对声称超越传统动物福利的系统的产品的接受程度和 WTP 密切相关,例如有机产品。在瑞士 8 家超市的 402 名消费者中进行的一项调查结果表明,淘汰雏鸡的做法在很大程度上不为人知(75%的受访者)。一般来说,受访者对家禽生产的了解程度较低。DP 替代品优于淘汰雏鸡,但 DP 与种蛋性别鉴定之间没有偏好。此外,消费者对 DP 产品的 WTP 比例低于鸡肉,而高于鸡蛋,这可能是由于这些产品之间的价格弹性不同。回归分析用于确定影响消费者 DP 产品 WTP 的因素。消费者的 WTP 与家禽生产知识、与购买有机或散养家禽产品相关的习惯以及对 DP 产品的熟悉程度呈正相关。因此,建议将 DP 替代品与有机标签相结合。