Waseem Hena, Mazzamurro Rachael S, Fisher Alec H, Bhowmik Subasish, Zaman Rifat A, Andrew Angeline, Bauer David F
1Department of Neurology.
2Division of Neurosurgery, Department of Surgery, Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth, Lebanon, New Hampshire.
J Neurosurg Pediatr. 2018 May;21(5):528-534. doi: 10.3171/2017.10.PEDS17261. Epub 2018 Feb 9.
OBJECTIVE Parental presence in the operating room during the induction of anesthesia (PPIA) has been shown to decrease parent and child anxiety and increase satisfaction with patient experience in outpatient otolaryngological procedures, such as tympanostomy tube placement. PPIA for other procedures, such as a major neurosurgical intervention, has been a practice at the authors' institutions for many years. This practice is not universally accepted across the United States, and the potential benefits for patients and families have not been formally evaluated. The aim of this study is to provide a qualitative analysis of parental and patient satisfaction with PPIA at the authors' institution. METHODS All patients younger than 18 years who underwent surgical intervention at the authors' institution between August 2013 and December 2015 were identified. All surgeries were performed by a single neurosurgeon. A random sample of 96 parents were contacted by telephone for a qualitative, semiscripted interview; 42 parents completed the interviews. The interview consisted of a validated satisfaction assessment in addition to a standardized open-ended questionnaire. Thematic analysis was performed until saturation was achieved, and responses were coded into the predominant themes. Member checking was performed, and a thick description was created. RESULTS The predominant themes identified with PPIA were 1) perception of induction as traumatizing or distressing to witness, 2) positive feelings regarding having been present, 3) satisfaction regarding the overall experience with surgery, 4) variable feelings in parents who decided not to attend induction, and 5) mixed feelings in the interactions with the care team. Parents expressed an array of positive, negative, and neutral impressions of the experience; however, overall, most experiences were positive. Most parents would choose PPIA again if their child required additional surgery. CONCLUSIONS This is the first study to evaluate the benefit of PPIA for pediatric neurosurgical patients. The results show a unique insight into medical communication and patient satisfaction with high-risk surgeries. PPIA may be able to help shape an environment of trust and increase satisfaction with perioperative care.
在门诊耳鼻喉科手术(如鼓膜置管术)中,麻醉诱导期间家长陪伴在手术室(PPIA)已被证明可降低家长和孩子的焦虑,并提高对患者体验的满意度。多年来,作者所在机构一直对其他手术(如重大神经外科干预手术)采用PPIA做法。这种做法在美国并未得到普遍认可,其对患者和家庭的潜在益处也尚未得到正式评估。本研究的目的是对作者所在机构家长和患者对PPIA的满意度进行定性分析。方法:确定2013年8月至2015年12月期间在作者所在机构接受手术干预的所有18岁以下患者。所有手术均由一名神经外科医生进行。通过电话联系96名家长进行定性的半脚本访谈;42名家长完成了访谈。访谈除了包含一份经过验证的满意度评估外,还有一份标准化的开放式问卷。进行主题分析直至达到饱和,并将回答编码为主导主题。进行了成员核对,并形成了详细描述。结果:与PPIA相关的主导主题为:1)认为诱导过程具有创伤性或目睹时令人痛苦;2)对在场有积极感受;3)对手术总体体验感到满意;4)决定不参加诱导的家长有不同感受;5)与护理团队互动时感受复杂。家长对该经历表达了一系列积极、消极和中性的印象;然而,总体而言,大多数经历是积极的。如果孩子需要再次手术,大多数家长会再次选择PPIA。结论:这是第一项评估PPIA对小儿神经外科患者益处的研究。结果显示了对医疗沟通和高危手术患者满意度的独特见解。PPIA可能有助于营造信任氛围并提高对围手术期护理的满意度。