Lisi Giuseppe, Rivela Diletta, Takai Asuka, Morimoto Jun
ATR Computational Neuroscience Laboratories, Department of Brain Robot Interface, Kyoto, Japan.
Front Neurosci. 2018 Feb 1;12:24. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2018.00024. eCollection 2018.
Quick detection of motor intentions is critical in order to minimize the time required to activate a neuroprosthesis. We propose a Markov Switching Model (MSM) to achieve quick detection of an event related desynchronization (ERD) elicited by motor imagery (MI) and recorded by electroencephalography (EEG). Conventional brain computer interfaces (BCI) rely on sliding window classifiers in order to perform online continuous classification of the rest vs. MI classes. Based on this approach, the detection of abrupt changes in the sensorimotor power suffers from an intrinsic delay caused by the necessity of computing an estimate of variance across several tenths of a second. Here we propose to avoid explicitly computing the EEG signal variance, and estimate the ERD state directly from the voltage information, in order to reduce the detection latency. This is achieved by using a model suitable in situations characterized by abrupt changes of state, the MSM. In our implementation, the model takes the form of a Gaussian observation model whose variance is governed by two latent discrete states with Markovian dynamics. Its objective is to estimate the brain state (i.e., rest vs. ERD) given the EEG voltage, spatially filtered by common spatial pattern (CSP), as observation. The two variances associated with the two latent states are calibrated using the variance of the CSP projection during rest and MI, respectively. The transition matrix of the latent states is optimized by the "quickest detection" strategy that minimizes a cost function of detection latency and false positive rate. Data collected by a dry EEG system from 50 healthy subjects, was used to assess performance and compare the MSM with several logistic regression classifiers of different sliding window lengths. As a result, the MSM achieves a significantly better tradeoff between latency, false positive and true positive rates. The proposed model could be used to achieve a more reactive and stable control of a neuroprosthesis. This is a desirable property in BCI-based neurorehabilitation, where proprioceptive feedback is provided based on the patient's brain signal. Indeed, it is hypothesized that simultaneous contingent association between brain signals and proprioceptive feedback induces superior associative learning.
为了将激活神经假体所需的时间减至最短,快速检测运动意图至关重要。我们提出一种马尔可夫切换模型(MSM),以实现对由运动想象(MI)引发并通过脑电图(EEG)记录的事件相关去同步化(ERD)的快速检测。传统的脑机接口(BCI)依靠滑动窗口分类器对静息状态与运动想象状态进行在线连续分类。基于这种方法,感觉运动功率的突然变化检测会受到因需要计算几十秒内的方差估计而导致的固有延迟的影响。在此,我们建议避免显式计算EEG信号方差,而是直接根据电压信息估计ERD状态,以减少检测延迟。这是通过使用适用于状态突然变化情况的模型——MSM来实现的。在我们的实现中,该模型采用高斯观测模型的形式,其方差由具有马尔可夫动力学的两个潜在离散状态控制。其目标是根据经共同空间模式(CSP)空间滤波后的EEG电压作为观测值来估计脑状态(即静息状态与ERD状态)。分别使用静息状态和运动想象状态期间CSP投影的方差来校准与两个潜在状态相关的两个方差。潜在状态的转移矩阵通过“最快检测”策略进行优化,该策略使检测延迟和误报率的成本函数最小化。由干式EEG系统从50名健康受试者收集的数据用于评估性能,并将MSM与不同滑动窗口长度的几个逻辑回归分类器进行比较。结果,MSM在延迟、误报率和真阳性率之间实现了明显更好的权衡。所提出的模型可用于实现对神经假体更具反应性和稳定性的控制。这在基于BCI的神经康复中是一个理想的特性,其中基于患者的脑信号提供本体感觉反馈。事实上,据推测,脑信号与本体感觉反馈之间的同时偶然关联会诱导更好的联想学习。