Walling Anne, Nilsen Kari, Callaway Paul, Grothusen Jill, Gillenwater Cole, King Samantha, Unruh Gregory
School of Medicine-Wichita, Department of Family and Community Medicine, University of Kansas Medical Center.
School of Medicine-Wichita, Office of Graduate Medical Education, University of Kansas Medical Center.
Kans J Med. 2017 Aug 30;10(3):1-15. eCollection 2017 Aug.
The student costs of residency interviewing are of increasing concern but limited current information is available. Updated, more detailed information would assist students and residency programs in decisions about residency selection. The study objective was to measure the expenses and time spent in residency interviewing by the 2016 graduating class of the University of Kansas School of Medicine and assess the impact of gender, regional campus location, and primary care application.
All 195 students who participated in the 2016 National Residency Matching Program (NRMP) received a 33 item questionnaire addressing interviewing activity, expenses incurred, time invested and related factors. Main measures were self-reported estimates of expenses and time spent interviewing. Descriptive analyses were applied to participant characteristics and responses. Multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) and chi-square tests compared students by gender, campus (main/regional), and primary care/other specialties. Analyses of variance (ANOVA) on the dependent variables provided follow-up tests on significant MANOVA results.
A total of 163 students (84%) completed the survey. The average student reported 38 (1-124) applications, 16 (1-54) invitations, 11 (1-28) completed interviews, and spent $3,500 ($20-$12,000) and 26 (1-90) days interviewing. No significant differences were found by gender. After MANOVA and ANOVA analyses, non-primary care applicants reported significantly more applications, interviews, and expenditures, but less program financial support. Regional campus students reported significantly fewer invitations, interviews, and days interviewing, but equivalent costs when controlled for primary care application. Cost was a limiting factor in accepting interviews for 63% and time for 53% of study respondents.
Students reported investing significant time and money in interviewing. After controlling for other variables, primary care was associated with significantly lowered expenses. Regional campus location was associated with fewer interviews and less time interviewing. Gender had no significant impact on any aspect studied.
住院医师面试中学生的花费日益受到关注,但目前可用信息有限。更新、更详细的信息将有助于学生和住院医师培训项目做出住院医师选择决策。本研究的目的是衡量堪萨斯大学医学院2016届毕业生在住院医师面试中的费用和时间,并评估性别、地区校区位置和初级保健申请的影响。
所有195名参加2016年全国住院医师匹配计划(NRMP)的学生都收到了一份包含33个项目的问卷,内容涉及面试活动、产生的费用、投入的时间及相关因素。主要衡量指标是自我报告的面试费用和时间估计。对参与者特征和回答进行描述性分析。多变量方差分析(MANOVA)和卡方检验按性别、校区(主校区/地区校区)以及初级保健/其他专业对学生进行比较。对因变量的方差分析(ANOVA)为显著的MANOVA结果提供后续检验。
共有163名学生(84%)完成了调查。平均每名学生报告申请了38次(1 - 124次),收到16次(1 - 54次)邀请,完成了11次(1 - 28次)面试,花费3500美元(20 - 12000美元),面试时间为26天(1 - 90天)。未发现性别间存在显著差异。经过MANOVA和ANOVA分析,非初级保健申请者报告的申请、面试和支出显著更多,但获得的项目资金支持更少。地区校区的学生收到的邀请、面试次数和面试天数显著更少,但在控制初级保健申请后费用相当。成本是63%的研究受访者接受面试的限制因素,时间是53%的研究受访者接受面试的限制因素。
学生报告在面试中投入了大量时间和金钱。在控制其他变量后,初级保健与费用显著降低相关。地区校区位置与面试次数减少和面试时间缩短相关。性别对所研究的任何方面均无显著影响。