Chatziioannidis Ilias, Bascialla Francesca Giuseppina, Chatzivalsama Panagiota, Vouzas Fotios, Mitsiakos Georgios
2nd Neonatal Intensive Care Unit, Faculty of Medicine, Aristotle University, G.P.N. Papageorgiou Hospital, Thessaloniki, Greece.
1st Psychiatric Clinic, Faculty of Medicine, Aristotle University, G.P.N. Papageorgiou Hospital, Thessaloniki, Greece.
BMJ Open. 2018 Feb 24;8(2):e018766. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2017-018766.
The aim of this study is to examine the prevalence, to report barriers and mental health impact of bullying behaviours and to analyse whether psychological support at work could affect victims of bullying in the healthcare workplace.
Self-administered questionnaire survey.
20 in total neonatal intensive care units in 17 hospitals in Greece.
398 healthcare professionals (doctors, nurses).
The questionnaire included information on demographic data, Negative Act Questionnaire-Revised (NAQ-R) behaviour scale, data on sources of bullying, perpetrators profile, causal factors, actions taken and reasons for not reporting bullying, psychological support and 12-item General Health Questionnaire (GHQ-12) scores to investigate psychological distress.
Prevalence of bullying measured by the NAQ-R was 53.1% for doctors and 53.6% for nurses. Victims of bullying differed from non-bullied in terms of gender and job experience, among demographic data. Crude NAQ-R score was found higher for female, young and inexperienced employees. Of those respondents who experienced bullying 44.9% self-labelled themselves as victims. Witnessing bullying of others was found 83.2%. Perpetrators were mainly females 45-64 years old, most likely being a supervisor/senior colleague. Common reasons for not reporting bullying was self-dealing and fear of consequences. Bullying was attributed to personality trait and management. Those who were bullied, self-labelled as a victim and witnessed bullying of others had higher GHQ-12 score. Moreover, psychological support at work had a favour effect on victims of bullying.
Prevalence of bullying and witnessing were found extremely high, while half of victims did not consider themselves as sufferers. The mental health impact on victims and witnesses was severe and support at work was necessary to ensure good mental health status among employees.
本研究旨在调查欺凌行为的发生率,报告其障碍因素及对心理健康的影响,并分析工作场所的心理支持是否会对医疗工作场所的欺凌受害者产生影响。
自行填写的问卷调查。
希腊17家医院共20个新生儿重症监护病房。
398名医疗专业人员(医生、护士)。
问卷包括人口统计学数据、修订版负面行为问卷(NAQ-R)行为量表、欺凌来源数据、实施者概况、因果因素、采取的行动及未报告欺凌行为的原因、心理支持以及用于调查心理困扰的12项一般健康问卷(GHQ-12)得分。
通过NAQ-R测量,医生的欺凌发生率为53.1%,护士为53.6%。在人口统计学数据方面,欺凌受害者在性别和工作经验上与未受欺凌者不同。发现女性、年轻和经验不足的员工的原始NAQ-R得分更高。在那些经历过欺凌的受访者中,44.9%的人自认为是受害者。发现目睹他人受欺凌的比例为83.2%。实施者主要是45 - 64岁的女性,最有可能是主管/资深同事。不报告欺凌行为的常见原因是自行处理和害怕后果。欺凌归因于人格特质和管理。那些受到欺凌、自认为是受害者且目睹他人受欺凌的人GHQ-12得分更高。此外,工作场所的心理支持对欺凌受害者有积极影响。
发现欺凌和目睹欺凌的发生率极高,而一半的受害者并不认为自己是受害者。欺凌对受害者和目睹者的心理健康影响严重,工作场所的支持对于确保员工良好的心理健康状况是必要的。