IEEE Trans Neural Syst Rehabil Eng. 2018 Mar;26(3):573-582. doi: 10.1109/TNSRE.2017.2771383.
Wearable inertial sensors have been widely investigated for fall risk assessment and prediction in older adults. However, heterogeneity in published studies in terms of sensor location, task assessed and features extracted is high, making challenging evidence-based design of new studies and/or real-life applications. We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis to appraise the best available evidence in the field. Namely, we applied established statistical methods for the analysis of categorical data to identify optimal combinations of sensor locations, tasks, and feature categories. We also conducted a meta-analysis on sensor-based features to identify a set of significant features and their pivot values. The results demonstrated that with a walking test, the most effective feature to assess the risk of falling was the velocity with the sensor placed on the shins. Conversely, during quite standing, linear acceleration measured at the lower back was the most effective combination of feature-placement. Similarly, during the sit-to-stand and/or the stand-to-sit tests, linear acceleration measured at the lower back seems to be the most effective feature-placement combination. The meta-analysis demonstrated that four features resulted significantly higher in fallers: the root-mean-square acceleration in the mediolateral direction during quiet standing with eyes closed [Mean Difference (MD): 0.01 g; 95% Confidence Interval (CI95%): 0.006 to 0.014]; the number of steps (MD: 1.638 steps; CI95%: 0.384 to 2.892) and total time (MD: 2.274 seconds; CI95%: 0.531 to 4.017) to complete the timed up and go test; and the step time (MD: 0.053; CI95%: 0.012 to 0.095; p = 0.01) during walking.
可穿戴惯性传感器已广泛应用于老年人跌倒风险评估和预测。然而,已发表的研究在传感器位置、评估任务和提取特征方面存在很大的异质性,这使得新研究和/或实际应用的基于证据的设计具有挑战性。我们进行了系统评价和荟萃分析,以评估该领域最佳的现有证据。具体来说,我们应用了用于分析分类数据的既定统计方法,以确定传感器位置、任务和特征类别的最佳组合。我们还对基于传感器的特征进行了荟萃分析,以确定一组显著特征及其枢轴值。结果表明,在行走测试中,评估跌倒风险最有效的特征是传感器放置在小腿上的速度。相反,在安静站立时,传感器放置在背部的线性加速度是特征放置的最有效组合。同样,在坐站和/或站坐测试中,传感器放置在背部的线性加速度似乎是最有效的特征放置组合。荟萃分析表明,在跌倒者中,有四个特征显著更高:闭眼安静站立时中侧方向的均方根加速度[均数差值(MD):0.01 g;95%置信区间(CI95%):0.006 至 0.014];完成计时起立行走测试的步数(MD:1.638 步;CI95%:0.384 至 2.892)和总时间(MD:2.274 秒;CI95%:0.531 至 4.017);以及行走时的步长时间(MD:0.053;CI95%:0.012 至 0.095;p = 0.01)。