Eberlin Marion, Chen Min, Mueck Tobias, Däbritz Jan
Department of Medical Affairs CHC GSA, Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland GmbH, Frankfurt am Main, Germany.
Department of Anesthesiology, Wuhan Union Hospital, Wuhan, China.
BMC Pediatr. 2018 Apr 3;18(1):124. doi: 10.1186/s12887-018-1095-x.
Racecadotril is a guideline-recommended option for the treatment of acute diarrhea in children but existing guidelines and previous reviews of the field are based on a small fraction of published evidence. Therefore, we have performed a systematic search for randomized controlled trials evaluating racecadotril as add-on or in comparison to other treatments.
A search was performed in PubMed, Scopus and Google Scholar without limits about country of origin or reporting language. A meta-analysis was conducted for the five most frequently used efficacy parameters.
We have retrieved 58 trials, from nine countries including six in comparison to placebo, 15 in comparison to various active treatments and 41 as add-on to various standard treatments (some multi-armed studies allowing more than one comparison). Trials used 45 distinct efficacy parameters, most often time to cure, % of cured children after 3 days of treatment, global efficacy and number of stools on second day of treatment. Racecadotril was superior to comparator treatments in outpatients and hospitalized patients with a high degree of consistency as confirmed by meta-analysis for the five most frequently used outcome parameters. For instance, it reduced time to cure from 106.2 h to 78.2 h (mean reduction 28.0 h; P < 0.0001 in 24 studies reporting on this parameter). Tolerability of racecadotril was comparable to that of placebo (10.4% vs. 10.6% adverse events incidence) or that of active comparator treatments other than loperamide (2.4% in both groups).
Based on a comprehensive review of the existing evidence, we conclude that racecadotril is more efficacious than other treatments except for loperamide and has a tolerability similar to placebo and better than loperamide. These findings support the use of racecadotril in the treatment of acute diarrhea in children.
消旋卡多曲是治疗儿童急性腹泻的指南推荐用药,但现有指南及该领域既往综述仅基于一小部分已发表证据。因此,我们对评估消旋卡多曲作为附加治疗或与其他治疗方法比较的随机对照试验进行了系统检索。
在PubMed、Scopus和谷歌学术中进行检索,对原产国或报告语言无限制。对五个最常用的疗效参数进行荟萃分析。
我们检索到58项试验,来自9个国家,其中6项试验比较了消旋卡多曲与安慰剂,15项试验比较了消旋卡多曲与各种活性治疗,41项试验将消旋卡多曲作为各种标准治疗的附加治疗(一些多组试验允许进行不止一种比较)。试验使用了45个不同的疗效参数,最常见的是治愈时间、治疗3天后治愈儿童的百分比、总体疗效以及治疗第二天的排便次数。荟萃分析证实,对于五个最常用的结局参数,消旋卡多曲在门诊患者和住院患者中均优于对照治疗,具有高度一致性。例如,它将治愈时间从106.2小时缩短至78.2小时(平均缩短28.0小时;在24项报告该参数的研究中,P<0.0001)。消旋卡多曲的耐受性与安慰剂相当(不良事件发生率分别为10.4%和10.6%),或与除洛哌丁胺外的活性对照治疗相当(两组均为2.4%)。
基于对现有证据的全面综述我们得出结论,除洛哌丁胺外,消旋卡多曲比其他治疗更有效,其耐受性与安慰剂相似且优于洛哌丁胺。这些发现支持消旋卡多曲用于治疗儿童急性腹泻。