Chatelan Angeline, Marques-Vidal Pedro, Bucher Sabine, Siegenthaler Stefan, Metzger Nathalie, Zuberbühler Christine Anne, Camenzind-Frey Esther, Reggli Andrea, Bochud Murielle, Beer-Borst Sigrid
1 Institute of Social and Preventive Medicine (IUMSP), Lausanne University Hospital (CHUV), Lausanne, Switzerland.
2 Department of Medicine, Internal Medicine, Lausanne University Hospital (CHUV), Lausanne, Switzerland.
Int J Vitam Nutr Res. 2017 Mar;87(1-2):25-36. doi: 10.1024/0300-9831/a000429. Epub 2018 Apr 20.
This paper informs about the implementation of the first trilingual Swiss nutrition pilot survey and lessons learnt in terms of recruitment, participation, data collection feasibility, and data management. The population-based cross-sectional nutrition pilot survey took place between June and November 2013. Six trained dietitians interviewed 276 adults aged 18-75 years residing in the cantons of Bern (German), Vaud (French) or Ticino (Italian). Food consumption was assessed with two non-consecutive computer-assisted 24-Hour Dietary Recalls (24HDR), applying a trilingual version of GloboDiet® adapted to specific requirements of Switzerland. The first interview was face-to-face and included anthropometric measurements while the second was by phone. Quality controls consisted mainly in the descriptive analysis of data at food level, and the observation and rating of 21 interviews (4%) by coordinators. Net participation rate was 29%. Participants and non-participants were similar: mean [±SD] age was 49±16 and 47±16 years, and women proportion 49.6% and 49.8%, respectively. Training and data collection proved feasible and deliverable in the six months using the newly developed survey instruments. Dietitians followed the standard operating procedures. Quality controls on food consumption data showed comparable results between face-to-face and phone 24HDR, and across dietitians (median number of reported food items per 24HDR: 27). Procedures to transfer and clean food consumption data were developed. The implementation concept proved applicable in the trilingual Swiss context. Additional resources were planned for increasing participation rate and facilitating data cleaning.
本文介绍了瑞士首次三语营养试点调查的实施情况,以及在招募、参与度、数据收集可行性和数据管理方面获得的经验教训。基于人群的横断面营养试点调查于2013年6月至11月进行。六名经过培训的营养师对居住在伯尔尼州(德语区)、沃州(法语区)或提契诺州(意大利语区)的276名18至75岁的成年人进行了访谈。采用经过调整以适应瑞士特定要求的三语版GloboDiet®,通过两次非连续的计算机辅助24小时膳食回顾(24HDR)来评估食物摄入量。第一次访谈是面对面进行的,包括人体测量,而第二次是通过电话进行。质量控制主要包括在食物层面进行数据描述性分析,以及由协调员对21次访谈(4%)进行观察和评分。净参与率为29%。参与者和非参与者相似:平均[±标准差]年龄分别为49±16岁和47±16岁,女性比例分别为49.6%和49.8%。使用新开发的调查工具,培训和数据收集在六个月内证明是可行且可交付的。营养师遵循标准操作程序。食物摄入量数据的质量控制显示,面对面和电话24HDR之间以及不同营养师之间的结果具有可比性(每次24HDR报告的食物项目中位数:27)。制定了转移和清理食物摄入量数据的程序。实施概念在瑞士三语环境中证明是适用的。计划增加额外资源以提高参与率并促进数据清理。