Department of Health Research Methods, Evidence and Impact, McMaster University, 1280 Main Street West, Hamilton, Ontario L8S 4K1, Canada; Centre for Health Economics and Policy Analysis, McMaster University, 1280 Main Street West, Hamilton, Ontario L8S 4K1, Canada.
Centre for Health Economics and Policy Analysis, McMaster University, 1280 Main Street West, Hamilton, Ontario L8S 4K1, Canada.
Prev Med. 2018 Jul;112:209-215. doi: 10.1016/j.ypmed.2018.04.021. Epub 2018 Apr 18.
Evolving scientific evidence about mammography has raised new questions about the net benefits of organized screening, yet gaps remain about women's current screening practices, knowledge, attitudes and values toward screening to support informed decision making in this area. We addressed this gap through an online survey of 2000 screen-eligible women from Ontario, Canada in January 2016. Likert-scaled and categorical questions were used to collect information about screening practices, knowledge of benefits and risks of screening and underlying attitudes and values toward screening. Results for all responses were summarized using descriptive statistics. Comparison of results between ever screened versus never screened respondents was performed using chi-squared tests. Most women felt informed about screening yet had doubts about how informed their decisions were. They were more confident in their knowledge of the benefits than the risks which aligned with the emphasis given to benefits in discussions with health care providers. The benefits of screening were linked with lowered anxiety about breast cancer. The never screened were less likely to overstate the benefits of screening, more likely to give weight to the risks, and less likely to report anxiety or worry about breast cancer. Findings highlight the need for improved communication strategies and decision supports that emphasize the provision of current, balanced information about the benefits and risks of screening, both at the population-level (through mass media) and within patient-provider interactions. Sensitivity to the psychosocial factors that shape women's attitudes toward mammography screening should be central to any strategy.
关于乳房 X 光检查的不断发展的科学证据提出了有关有组织筛查净效益的新问题,但仍存在有关女性当前筛查实践、对筛查的知识、态度和价值观的差距,以支持在这一领域做出明智的决策。我们通过 2016 年 1 月对加拿大安大略省 2000 名符合筛查条件的女性进行的在线调查来解决这一差距。使用李克特量表和分类问题收集有关筛查实践、筛查的益处和风险的知识以及对筛查的潜在态度和价值观的信息。使用描述性统计汇总所有答复的结果。使用卡方检验比较曾接受过筛查与从未接受过筛查的受访者的结果。大多数女性认为自己对筛查有一定的了解,但对自己的决策是否明智存在疑虑。她们对筛查益处的了解更有信心,而对风险的了解则不太确定,这与在与医疗保健提供者的讨论中对益处的强调一致。筛查的益处与降低对乳腺癌的焦虑感有关。从未接受过筛查的女性不太可能夸大筛查的益处,更有可能重视风险,不太可能报告对乳腺癌的焦虑或担忧。研究结果强调需要改进沟通策略和决策支持,重点是提供关于筛查的益处和风险的当前、平衡的信息,无论是在人群层面(通过大众媒体)还是在医患互动中。关注影响女性对乳房 X 光检查态度的心理社会因素应该是任何策略的核心。