Clinical Pharmacology, Roche/Genentech, Marseille, France.
Clinical Pharmacology, Roche/Genentech, South San Francisco, California.
Clin Cancer Res. 2018 Jul 15;24(14):3292-3298. doi: 10.1158/1078-0432.CCR-17-3662. Epub 2018 Apr 23.
Standard endpoints often poorly predict overall survival (OS) with immunotherapies. We investigated the predictive performance of model-based tumor growth inhibition (TGI) metrics using data from atezolizumab clinical trials in patients with non-small cell lung cancer. OS benefit with atezolizumab versus docetaxel was observed in both POPLAR (phase II) and OAK (phase III), although progression-free survival was similar between arms. A multivariate model linking baseline patient characteristics and on-treatment tumor growth rate constant (KG), estimated using time profiles of sum of longest diameters (RECIST 1.1) to OS, was developed using POPLAR data. The model was evaluated to predict OAK outcome based on estimated KG at TGI data cutoffs ranging from 10 to 122 weeks. In POPLAR, TGI profiles in both arms crossed at 25 weeks, with more shrinkage with docetaxel and slower KG with atezolizumab. A log-normal OS model, with albumin and number of metastatic sites as independent prognostic factors and estimated KG, predicted OS HR in subpopulations of patients with varying baseline PD-L1 expression in both POPLAR and OAK: model-predicted OAK HR (95% prediction interval), 0.73 (0.63-0.85), versus 0.73 observed. The POPLAR OS model predicted greater than 97% chance of success of OAK (significant OS HR, < 0.05) from the 40-week data cutoff onward with 50% of the total number of tumor assessments when a successful study was predicted from 70 weeks onward based on observed OS. KG has potential as a model-based early endpoint to inform decisions in cancer immunotherapy studies. .
标准终点通常无法很好地预测免疫疗法的总生存期(OS)。我们使用来自阿特珠单抗治疗非小细胞肺癌患者的临床试验数据,研究了基于模型的肿瘤生长抑制(TGI)指标的预测性能。尽管两组之间无进展生存期相似,但阿特珠单抗与多西他赛相比,在 POPLAR(II 期)和 OAK(III 期)中均观察到 OS 获益。使用来自 POPLAR 数据的基线患者特征和治疗中肿瘤生长率常数(KG)的多元模型,通过时间最长直径总和(RECIST 1.1)的治疗肿瘤生长率常数(KG)的时间曲线进行估计。使用来自 POPLAR 的数据来预测 OAK 结果,评估了该模型在 TGI 数据截止点(10 至 122 周)范围内估计的 KG。在 POPLAR 中,两组的 TGI 曲线在 25 周时相交,多西他赛组肿瘤收缩更快,阿特珠单抗组 KG 更慢。使用对数正态 OS 模型,以白蛋白和转移性部位数量作为独立预后因素和估计的 KG,预测了不同基线 PD-L1 表达的患者亚组在 POPLAR 和 OAK 中的 OS HR:模型预测的 OAK HR(95%预测区间)为 0.73(0.63-0.85),与观察到的 0.73 一致。POPLAR OS 模型预测,从 40 周数据截止日期开始,OAK(显著 OS HR,<0.05)成功的可能性超过 97%,而基于观察到的 OS,从 70 周开始,当预测研究成功时,需要进行 50%的总肿瘤评估次数。KG 有潜力成为癌症免疫治疗研究中基于模型的早期终点,为决策提供信息。