Department of Internal Medicine, Section of Cardiovascular Medicine, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, CT
Department of Internal Medicine, Section of Cardiovascular Medicine, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, CT.
J Am Heart Assoc. 2018 May 17;7(11):e008663. doi: 10.1161/JAHA.118.008663.
Physical activity is predictive of cardiovascular outcomes in patients with cardiovascular implantable electronic devices, yet it is not regularly assessed in routine care. Current-generation cardiovascular implantable electronic devices, however, continuously monitor patient activity through a built-in accelerometer, which provides new opportunities to remotely assess patient activity, detect changes in clinical status, and incorporate these data in risk stratification models. This review critically examines the literature on device-measured physical activity (D-PA), with a focus on identifying methodological issues that may affect interpretation of study results.
We conducted a systematic review of D-PA studies published from January 1 1995 to December 30 2017, identifying 29 studies meeting inclusion criteria, 5 of which were validation reports. Few technical details about D-PA sensors are reported, and procedures for analyzing and interpreting D-PA data are heterogeneous. Trends in D-PA over time and associations with clinical outcomes were reported by 22 studies, and in 7 studies, D-PA was combined with other device parameters in risk stratification models, demonstrating modest-to-good sensitivity in predicting acute heart failure decompensation, hospitalization, and mortality.
Current evidence suggests that D-PA may be useful for assessing physical activity and predicting clinical outcomes in patients with cardiovascular implantable electronic devices when combined with other device parameters. Future work must address challenges related to D-PA data measurement, interpretation, and generalizability to support expanded clinical applications of this technology.
体力活动可预测心血管植入电子设备患者的心血管结局,但在常规护理中并未定期评估。然而,当前代心血管植入电子设备通过内置加速度计连续监测患者的活动,这为远程评估患者活动、检测临床状况变化以及将这些数据纳入风险分层模型提供了新的机会。本综述批判性地审查了关于设备测量体力活动(D-PA)的文献,重点是确定可能影响研究结果解释的方法学问题。
我们对 1995 年 1 月 1 日至 2017 年 12 月 30 日期间发表的 D-PA 研究进行了系统评价,确定了符合纳入标准的 29 项研究,其中 5 项为验证报告。很少有关于 D-PA 传感器的技术细节报告,并且分析和解释 D-PA 数据的程序存在异质性。22 项研究报告了 D-PA 随时间的变化趋势及其与临床结局的关联,7 项研究将 D-PA 与其他设备参数结合用于风险分层模型,证明了其在预测急性心力衰竭失代偿、住院和死亡率方面具有适度至良好的敏感性。
目前的证据表明,当与其他设备参数结合使用时,D-PA 可能有助于评估心血管植入电子设备患者的体力活动和预测临床结局。未来的工作必须解决与 D-PA 数据测量、解释和推广性相关的挑战,以支持该技术的广泛临床应用。