Lu Chuntao, Hu Yinhuan, Xie Jinzhu, Fu Qiang, Leigh Isabella, Governor Samuel, Wang Guanping
School of Medicine and Health Management, Tongji Medical College, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, China.
Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, College for Public Health and Social Justice, Saint Louis University, Missouri, MO, United States.
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2018 May 23;6(5):e126. doi: 10.2196/mhealth.9145.
The proliferation of mobile health apps has greatly changed the way society accesses the health care industry. However, despite the widespread use of mobile health apps by patients in China, there has been little research that evaluates the effect of mobile health apps on patient experience during hospital visits.
The purpose of our study was to examine whether the use of mobile health apps improves patient experience and to find out the difference in patient experience between users and nonusers and the characteristics associated with the users of these apps.
We used the Chinese Outpatient Experience Questionnaire to survey patient experience. A sample of 300 outpatients was randomly selected from 3 comprehensive public hospitals (3 tertiary hospitals) in Hubei province, China. Each hospital randomly selected 50 respondents from mobile health app users and 50 from nonusers. A chi-square test was employed to compare the different categorical characteristics between mobile health app users and nonusers. A t test was used to test the significance in continuous variables between user scores and nonuser scores. Multiple linear regression was conducted to determine whether the use of mobile health apps during hospital visits was associated with patient experience.
The users and nonusers differed in age (χ=12.2, P=.002), education (χ=9.3, P=.03), living place (χ=7.7, P=.006), and the need for specialists (χ=11.0, P=.03). Compared with nonusers, mobile health app users in China were younger, better educated, living in urban areas, and had higher demands for specialists. In addition, mobile health app users gave significantly higher scores than nonusers in total patient experience scores (t=3.919, P<.001), the 18 items and the 5 dimensions of physician-patient communication (t=2.93, P=.004), health information (t=3.556, P<.001), medical service fees (t=3.991, P<.001), short-term outcome (t=4.533, P<.001), and general satisfaction (t=4.304, P<.001). Multiple linear regression results showed that the use of mobile health apps during hospital visits influenced patient experience (t=3.143, P=.002). After controlling for other factors, it was shown that the use of mobile health apps increased the outpatient experience scores by 17.7%. Additional results from the study found that the self-rated health status (t=3.746, P<.001) and monthly income of patients (t=2.416, P=.02) influenced the patient experience as well.
The use of mobile health apps could improve patient experience, especially with regard to accessing health information, making physician-patient communication more convenient, ensuring transparency in medical charge, and ameliorating short-term outcomes. All of these may contribute to positive health outcomes. Therefore, we should encourage the adoption of mobile health apps in health care settings so as to improve patient experience.
移动健康应用程序的激增极大地改变了社会接触医疗行业的方式。然而,尽管中国患者广泛使用移动健康应用程序,但很少有研究评估移动健康应用程序对患者就医体验的影响。
我们研究的目的是检验使用移动健康应用程序是否能改善患者体验,并找出用户与非用户在患者体验上的差异以及与这些应用程序用户相关的特征。
我们使用中国门诊患者体验问卷来调查患者体验。从中国湖北省的3家综合性公立医院(3家三级医院)中随机抽取300名门诊患者作为样本。每家医院从移动健康应用程序用户中随机抽取50名受访者,从非用户中随机抽取50名。采用卡方检验比较移动健康应用程序用户与非用户之间不同的分类特征。使用t检验来检验用户得分与非用户得分在连续变量上的显著性。进行多元线性回归以确定在医院就诊期间使用移动健康应用程序是否与患者体验相关。
用户和非用户在年龄(χ=12.2,P=0.002)、教育程度(χ=9.3,P=0.03)、居住地点(χ=7.7,P=0.006)以及对专家的需求(χ=11.0,P=0.03)方面存在差异。与非用户相比,中国的移动健康应用程序用户更年轻、受教育程度更高、居住在城市地区,并且对专家有更高的需求。此外,移动健康应用程序用户在总患者体验得分(t=3.919,P<0.001)、医患沟通的18项内容和5个维度(t=2.93,P=0.004)、健康信息(t=3.556,P<0.001)、医疗服务费(t=3.991,P<0.001)、短期结果(t=4.533,P<0.001)以及总体满意度(t=4.304,P<0.001)方面的得分明显高于非用户。多元线性回归结果表明,在医院就诊期间使用移动健康应用程序会影响患者体验(t=3.143,P=0.002)。在控制其他因素后,结果显示使用移动健康应用程序使门诊患者体验得分提高了17.7%。该研究的其他结果还发现,患者的自评健康状况(t=3.746,P<0.001)和月收入(t=2.416,P=0.02)也会影响患者体验。
使用移动健康应用程序可以改善患者体验,特别是在获取健康信息、使医患沟通更便捷、确保医疗费用透明以及改善短期结果方面。所有这些都可能有助于产生积极的健康结果。因此,我们应该鼓励在医疗环境中采用移动健康应用程序,以改善患者体验。