Clegg Tracy A, Good Margaret, Hayes Martin, Duignan Anthony, McGrath Guy, More Simon J
Centre for Veterinary Epidemiology and Risk Analysis, UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, University College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
Independent Researcher and Private Consultant (previously affiliated with the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Dublin), Dun Laoghaire, Ireland.
Front Vet Sci. 2018 May 23;5:86. doi: 10.3389/fvets.2018.00086. eCollection 2018.
Persistence of bovine tuberculosis (bTB) in cattle is an important feature of infection, presenting either as herd recurrence or local persistence. One risk factor associated with the risk of recurrent episodes is the severity of a previous bTB episode (severity reflecting the number of bTB reactors identified during the episode). In this study, we have sought to identify predictors that can distinguish between small (less severe) and large (more severe) bTB episodes, and to describe nationally the severity of bTB episodes over time. The study included descriptive statistics of the proportion of episodes by severity from 2004 to 2015 and a case-control study. The case-control study population included all herds with at least one episode beginning in 2014 or 2015, with at least two full herd tests during the episode and a minimum herd-size of 60 animals. Case herds included study herds with at least 13 reactors whereas control herds had between 2 to 4 (inclusive) reactors during the first 2 tests of the episode. A logistic regression model was developed to identify risk factors associated with a large episode. Although there has been a general trend towards less severe herd bTB episodes in Ireland over time (2004-2015), the proportion of large episodes has remained relatively consistent. From the case-control study, the main predictors of a large episode were the year the episode started, increasing herd-size, previous exposure to bTB, increasing bTB incidence in the local area, an animal with a bTB lesion and a bTB episode in an associated herd. Herds that introduced more animals were more likely to have a smaller bTB episode, reflecting the reduced risk of within-herd transmission when an episode was due to an introduced infected bTB animal. Some of the risk factors identified in this study such as reactors in previous bTB episodes, herds with an associated herd undergoing a bTB episode, herds in high incidence areas etc. may help to target future policy measures to specific herds or animals for additional surveillance measures. This information has important policy implications.
牛结核病(bTB)在牛群中的持续存在是感染的一个重要特征,表现为牛群复发或局部持续存在。与复发风险相关的一个危险因素是先前bTB发作的严重程度(严重程度反映发作期间确定的bTB反应动物数量)。在本研究中,我们试图确定能够区分小型(不太严重)和大型(更严重)bTB发作的预测因素,并描述全国范围内bTB发作严重程度随时间的变化情况。该研究包括2004年至2015年按严重程度划分的发作比例的描述性统计以及一项病例对照研究。病例对照研究人群包括所有在2014年或2015年开始至少有一次发作、发作期间至少进行两次全群检测且最小牛群规模为60头动物的牛群。病例牛群包括在发作的前两次检测中有至少13头反应动物的研究牛群,而对照牛群在发作的前两次检测中有2至4头(含)反应动物。开发了一个逻辑回归模型来确定与大型发作相关的危险因素。尽管随着时间推移(2004 - 2015年)爱尔兰牛群中bTB发作的严重程度总体呈下降趋势,但大型发作的比例一直相对稳定。从病例对照研究来看,大型发作的主要预测因素是发作开始的年份、牛群规模增加、先前接触过bTB、当地bTB发病率增加、有bTB病变的动物以及相关牛群中有bTB发作。引入更多动物的牛群更有可能出现较小的bTB发作,这反映出当发作是由引入的感染bTB动物引起时,牛群内传播风险降低。本研究中确定的一些危险因素,如先前bTB发作中的反应动物、有相关牛群正在经历bTB发作的牛群、高发病率地区的牛群等,可能有助于将未来的政策措施针对特定牛群或动物,以采取额外的监测措施。这些信息具有重要的政策意义。