Leibniz Institute for Science and Mathematics Education, Kiel, Germany.
Centre for International Student Assessment, Kiel, Munich, and Frankfurt, Germany.
J Pers. 2019 Jun;87(3):593-606. doi: 10.1111/jopy.12418. Epub 2018 Aug 30.
Our study addressed three questions concerning the similarity of vocational interests within families: (a) How similar are vocational interests of mothers and fathers? (b) How similar are vocational interests of parents and their children? (c) Is the inference about parent-child profile similarity affected by mother-father profile similarity?
Data from N=1,624 tenth graders and their parents were used to analyze interest profile similarity by means of a pseudo-coupling approach. Similarity was assessed on the level of observed profiles and model-based circumplex profiles.
Interest profiles of mother-father and parent-child dyads were more similar to each other than those of corresponding arbitrarily paired dyads. However, when the similarity between the parents' interest profiles was accounted for, only same-sex parent-child dyads were more similar to each other than would be expected by chance. All findings were mirrored on the level of observed profiles and model-based circumplex profiles.
In sum, our findings support the validity of the circumplex model of vocational interests and emphasize the benefits of explicitly considering its implications when analyzing profile similarity. Moreover, we were able to show that the statistical evaluation of profile similarities must account for normative profile components.
本研究探讨了家庭内部职业兴趣相似性的三个问题:(a)父母的职业兴趣有多相似?(b)父母和他们的孩子的职业兴趣有多相似?(c)父母职业兴趣相似性的推断是否受父母职业兴趣相似性的影响?
本研究使用了来自 1624 名十年级学生及其父母的数据,通过拟耦合方法分析了兴趣模式的相似性。相似性在观察到的模式和基于模型的环面模式上进行评估。
与任意配对的对偶相比,母亲-父亲和父母-子女对偶的兴趣模式更为相似。然而,当考虑到父母的兴趣模式之间的相似性时,只有同性别的父母-子女对偶比随机预期的更为相似。所有发现都反映在观察到的模式和基于模型的环面模式上。
总之,我们的发现支持职业兴趣的环面模型的有效性,并强调在分析模式相似性时明确考虑其含义的益处。此外,我们能够表明,模式相似性的统计评估必须考虑规范的模式组成部分。