Simmonds A P, Hamilton P S, Kerr H, Harvey K, Moyes P, Davidson K G, Faichney A
Br J Cancer. 1986 Oct;54(4):587-94. doi: 10.1038/bjc.1986.213.
Lung tumours of non small cell pathology were cultured by clonogenic assay in several media. Culture was successful in spleen conditioned medium, but only 57% grew and low plating efficiencies (PE) meant that only 23% of the original number produced significant drug results. Comparison of rat erythrocyte lysate (REL) medium with serum free defined medium (HITES) and HITES + 10% FBS demonstrated clear enhancement of PE in REL although growth was 100% successful in all these media. Ninety-three percent of samples tested against drugs in REL produced significant results. A later comparison of REL with McCoy's 5A + rbc +/- hydrocortisone produced relatively poor culture success for these 3 media and equivocal growth patterns. Low PE was attributed to age of rats used for rbc. Vindesine and cis-platinum cytotoxicity in spleen conditioned medium were 61% and 15% sensitivity respectively. These do not concur with clinical experience but the figures for overt resistance, at 39% and 69%, correspond with expected non-responders to these regimes. Drug testing in REL produced figures correlating more closely with clinical performance at 45% sensitivity to platinum and 36% of patients sensitive to both drugs, but the vindesine sensitivity at 55% is again discrepant with performance of this drug as a single agent.
采用克隆形成试验在多种培养基中培养非小细胞病理类型的肺肿瘤。在脾条件培养基中培养成功,但只有57%生长,且低接种效率意味着只有23%的原始细胞数量产生显著的药物结果。将大鼠红细胞裂解物(REL)培养基与无血清限定培养基(HITES)以及HITES + 10%胎牛血清进行比较,结果表明REL中接种效率明显提高,尽管在所有这些培养基中生长成功率均为100%。在REL中对药物进行测试的样本中有93%产生了显著结果。后来将REL与添加或不添加氢化可的松的 McCoy's 5A + 红细胞进行比较,这三种培养基的培养成功率相对较低,生长模式不明确。低接种效率归因于用于获取红细胞的大鼠的年龄。长春地辛和顺铂在脾条件培养基中的细胞毒性敏感性分别为61%和15%。这些结果与临床经验不一致,但明显耐药的比例分别为39%和69%,与这些治疗方案预期的无反应者相符。在REL中进行药物测试得出的数据与临床疗效的相关性更高,对铂的敏感性为45%,对两种药物均敏感的患者为36%,但长春地辛作为单一药物时55%的敏感性再次与该药的实际疗效不符。