Tian Yin, Zhang Huiling, Pang Yu, Lin Jinzhao
College of Bio-information, Chongqing University of Posts and Telecommunications, Chongqing, China.
Front Comput Neurosci. 2018 Sep 13;12:68. doi: 10.3389/fncom.2018.00068. eCollection 2018.
Whether an event-related potential (ERP), N170, related to facial recognition was modulated by emotion has always been a controversial issue. Some researchers considered the N170 to be independent of emotion, whereas a recent study has shown the opposite view. In the current study, electroencephalogram (EEG) recordings while responding to facial pictures with emotion were utilized to investigate whether the N170 was modulated by emotion. We found that there was a significant difference between ERP trials with positive and negative emotions of around 170 ms at the occipitotemporal electrodes (i.e., N170). Then, we further proposed the application of the single-trial N170 as a feature for the classification of facial emotion, which could avoid the fact that ERPs were obtained by averaging most of the time while ignoring the trial-to-trial variation. In order to find an optimal classifier for emotional classification with single-trial N170 as a feature, three types of classifiers, namely, linear discriminant analysis (LDA), L1-regularized logistic regression (L1LR), and support vector machine with radial basis function (RBF-SVM), were comparatively investigated. The results showed that the single-trial N170 could be used as a classification feature to successfully distinguish positive emotion from negative emotion. L1-regularized logistic regression classifiers showed a good generalization, whereas LDA showed a relatively poor generalization. Moreover, when compared with L1LR, the RBF-SVM required more time to optimize the parameters during the classification, which became an obstacle while applying it to the online operating system of brain-computer interfaces (BCIs). The findings suggested that face-related N170 could be affected by facial expression and that the single-trial N170 could be a biomarker used to monitor the emotional states of subjects for the BCI domain.
与面部识别相关的事件相关电位(ERP)即N170是否会受到情绪的调制一直是一个有争议的问题。一些研究人员认为N170与情绪无关,而最近的一项研究则显示了相反的观点。在本研究中,利用对带有情绪的面部图片做出反应时的脑电图(EEG)记录来研究N170是否会受到情绪的调制。我们发现在枕颞电极处,大约170毫秒时,正性和负性情绪的ERP试验之间存在显著差异(即N170)。然后,我们进一步提出将单次试验的N170作为面部情绪分类的一个特征来应用,这可以避免ERP大多时候是通过平均得到而忽略了试验间变化这一事实。为了找到以单次试验N170为特征进行情绪分类的最优分类器,对三种类型的分类器,即线性判别分析(LDA)、L1正则化逻辑回归(L1LR)和径向基函数支持向量机(RBF - SVM)进行了比较研究。结果表明,单次试验的N170可以作为一种分类特征,成功地区分正性情绪和负性情绪。L1正则化逻辑回归分类器表现出良好的泛化能力,而LDA的泛化能力相对较差。此外,与L1LR相比,RBF - SVM在分类过程中需要更多时间来优化参数,这在将其应用于脑机接口(BCI)的在线操作系统时成为了一个障碍。这些发现表明,与面部相关的N170可能会受到面部表情的影响,并且单次试验的N170可以作为一种生物标志物,用于在BCI领域监测受试者的情绪状态。