Etamesor Sulaiman, Ottih Chibuzo, Salihu Ismail Ndalami, Okpani Arnold Ikedichi
National Primary Health Care Development Agency, Abuja, Nigeria.
BMJ Glob Health. 2018 Oct 2;3(5):e000807. doi: 10.1136/bmjgh-2018-000807. eCollection 2018.
Availability of reliable data has for a long time been a challenge for health programmes in Nigeria. Routine immunisation (RI) data have always been characterised by conflicting coverage figures for the same vaccine across different routine data reporting platforms. Following the adoption of District Health Information System version 2 (DHIS2) as a national electronic data management platform, the DHIS2 RI Dashboard Project was initiated to address the absence of some RI-specific indicators on DHIS2. The project was also intended to improve visibility and monitoring of RI indicators as well as strengthen the broader national health management information system by promoting the use of routine data for decision making at all governance levels. This paper documents the process, challenges and lessons learnt in implementing the project in Nigeria. A multistakeholder technical working group developed an implementation framework with clear preimplementation; implementation and postimplementation activities. Beginning with a pilot in Kano state in 2014, the project has been scaled up countrywide. Nearly 34 000 health workers at all administrative levels were trained on RI data tools and DHIS2 use. The project contributed to the improvement in completeness of reports on DHIS2 from 53 % in first quarter 2014 to 81 % in second quarter 2017. The project faced challenges relating to primary healthcare governance structures at the subnational level, infrastructure and human resource capacity. Our experience highlights the need for early and sustained advocacy to stakeholders in a decentralised health system to promote ownership and sustainability of a centrally coordinated systems strengthening initiative.
长期以来,获取可靠数据一直是尼日利亚卫生项目面临的一项挑战。常规免疫(RI)数据的特点始终是,在不同的常规数据报告平台上,同一种疫苗的覆盖数据相互矛盾。在采用地区卫生信息系统2.0版(DHIS2)作为国家电子数据管理平台之后,启动了DHIS2常规免疫仪表盘项目,以解决DHIS2上缺少一些特定于常规免疫的指标的问题。该项目还旨在提高常规免疫指标的可见性和监测水平,并通过促进在各级治理层面利用常规数据进行决策,来加强更广泛的国家卫生管理信息系统。本文记录了在尼日利亚实施该项目的过程、挑战和经验教训。一个多利益相关方技术工作组制定了一个实施框架,其中包括明确的实施前、实施和实施后活动。该项目于2014年在卡诺州开展试点,之后在全国范围内推广。各级行政层面近34000名卫生工作者接受了常规免疫数据工具和DHIS2使用方面的培训。该项目促使DHIS2报告的完整性从2014年第一季度的53%提高到2017年第二季度的81%。该项目面临与国家以下层面的初级卫生保健治理结构、基础设施和人力资源能力相关的挑战。我们的经验凸显了在分散式卫生系统中,需要尽早并持续地向利益相关方进行宣传,以促进由中央协调的系统强化举措的自主性和可持续性。