Padhiyar Rupal, Chavan Swati, Dhampalwar Swapnil, Trivedi Trupti, Moulick Nivedita
Associate Professor.
Professor.
J Assoc Physicians India. 2018 Mar;66(3):55-9.
In India, it is estimated that up to 20,000 people die annually from snake bites. The present study was carried to out to estimate the snake bite related epidemiology, predictors of severity, relationship between type of snake, clinical severity, complications, outcome and usage pattern of polyvalent anti snake venom (ASV) in a tertiary care center.
All indoor patients admitted in our institute with definitive history of bite by a snake, with or without presence of fang marks, Evidence of cellulitis, acute onset of neurotoxicity or bleeding diathesis were serially recruited in the study.
The majority of cases were in the range of 21- 40 years (54.7%). There were 82.8% males (53/64), 17.2% females (11/64) and 60.9% (39/64) bites were during day time. Upper limb bites were seen in 34% (22/64) of the patients and lower limb bites in 54% (35/64), and axial body bites in 6%. There were 43.8% (28/64) vasculotoxic bites, 34.4% (22/64) neurotoxic bites and 20.3% (14/64) non-poisonous bites. Viper was the most common (9%) identified snake, followed by krait (5%). References from Rural Health Centers were 57.8% (57/64), 11% were from Primary health centers and rest from private sector. Anti snake venom (ASV) was received by 68.75% (44/64) patients before reaching tertiary care. Local swelling was present in 90.6% (58/64) patients, Systemic bleeding was seen in 35.9% (23/64), and Neuromuscular weakness in 35.9% (23/64) patients. Complications like Respiratory paralysis developed in 18.75% (12/64), Acute kidney injury in 12% (8/64), DIC in 9% (6/64), and hepatic involvement in 7% (5/64) of snake bite patients. Blood transfusion was required in 20.3% (13/64) p<0.001), 18.75% (12/64) required Mechanical ventilation (p=0.001), 4 received hemodailysis and 4 required ionotropic support (p<0.001). Improvement was seen in 57.8% (37/64), morbidity during hospital stay was seen in 39% (25/64) and 2 patients expired (3%). ASV was received within 4 hours in 67% (42/64) patients, 22.5% (14/64) received ASV between 4 to 24 hours and remaining after 24 hours (p=0.016). Total ASV requierment was 24.05 vials in patients who improved and 34.4vials in patients in Morbid group and 29.0 vials in mortality group (p>0.05). The SSS score amongst improved was 4.76 ± 2.46 whereas among morbid, it was 8.48 ± 1.75 and amongst expired, it was 8.5 ± 0.707 (p<0.05).
Patients requiring various supportive treatments like blood transfusion, Inotropes, Haemodialysis and Mechanical ventilation, had a statistically significant correlation with poor outcome. Early administration of ASV that is within 4 hours was, associated with better outcome. The total amount of ASV (in vials) had no a significant correlation with outcome. Snakebite Severity Score correlates significantly with early recovery in vasculotoxic snake bites (p=0.03).
在印度,据估计每年有多达20000人死于蛇咬伤。本研究旨在评估一家三级医疗中心蛇咬伤相关的流行病学、严重程度预测因素、蛇的种类与临床严重程度的关系、并发症、结局以及多价抗蛇毒血清(ASV)的使用模式。
本研究连续纳入我院所有有明确蛇咬伤史的住院患者,无论有无牙痕、蜂窝织炎证据、急性神经毒性发作或出血倾向。
大多数病例年龄在21 - 40岁之间(54.7%)。男性占82.8%(53/64),女性占17.2%(11/64),60.9%(39/64)的咬伤发生在白天。34%(22/64)的患者上肢被咬伤,54%(35/64)下肢被咬伤,6%为躯干咬伤。43.8%(28/64)为血管毒性咬伤,34.4%(22/64)为神经毒性咬伤,20.3%(14/64)为无毒咬伤。蝰蛇是最常见的被识别出的蛇(9%),其次是金环蛇(5%)。来自农村卫生中心的病例占57.8%(57/64),11%来自初级卫生中心,其余来自私立部门。68.75%(44/64)的患者在到达三级医疗机构之前接受了抗蛇毒血清(ASV)治疗。90.6%(58/64)的患者出现局部肿胀,35.9%(23/64)出现全身出血,35.9%(23/64)的患者出现神经肌肉无力。18.75%(12/64)的蛇咬伤患者出现呼吸麻痹等并发症,12%(8/64)出现急性肾损伤,9%(6/64)出现弥散性血管内凝血,7%(5/64)出现肝脏受累。20.3%(13/64)的患者需要输血(p<0.001),18.75%(12/64)需要机械通气(p = 0.001),4例接受血液透析,4例需要血管活性药物支持(p<0.001)。57.8%(37/64)的患者病情好转,39%(25/64)的患者在住院期间出现并发症,2例患者死亡(3%)。67%(42/64)的患者在4小时内接受了ASV治疗,22.5%(14/64)在4至24小时之间接受了ASV治疗,其余在24小时之后接受治疗(p = 0.016)。病情好转的患者ASV总需求量为24.05瓶,病情严重组患者为34.4瓶,死亡组患者为29.0瓶(p>0.05)。病情好转患者的蛇咬伤严重程度评分(SSS)为4.76±2.46,病情严重患者为8.48±1.75,死亡患者为8.5±0.707(p<0.05)。
需要输血、血管活性药物、血液透析和机械通气等各种支持治疗的患者与不良结局存在统计学显著相关性。在4小时内早期给予ASV与更好的结局相关。ASV的总量(瓶数)与结局无显著相关性。蛇咬伤严重程度评分与血管毒性蛇咬伤的早期恢复显著相关(p = 0.03)。