CNR-IRCrES, Research Institute on Sustainable Economic Growth, Moncalieri, Italy.
Clinical Medicine Department, Fondazione IRCCS, Ca' Granda, Ospedale Maggiore Policlinico, Milan, Italy.
Intern Emerg Med. 2019 Mar;14(2):291-299. doi: 10.1007/s11739-018-1971-2. Epub 2018 Oct 23.
Emergency departments are characterized by the need for quick diagnosis under pressure. To select the most appropriate treatment, a series of rules to support decision-making has been offered by scientific societies. The effectiveness of these rules affects the appropriateness of treatment and the hospitalization of patients. Analyzing a sample of 1844 patients and focusing on the decision to hospitalize a patient after a syncope event to prevent severe short-term outcomes, this work proposes a new algorithm based on neural networks. Artificial neural networks are a non-parametric technique with the well-known ability to generalize behaviors, and they can thus predict severe short-term outcomes with pre-selected levels of sensitivity and specificity. This innovative technique can outperform the traditional models, since it does not require a specific functional form, i.e., the data are not supposed to be distributed following a specific design. Based on our results, the innovative model can predict hospitalization with a sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of 79%, significantly increasing the appropriateness of medical treatment and, as a result, hospital efficiency. According to Garson's Indexes, the most significant variables are exertion, the absence of symptoms, and the patient's gender. On the contrary, cardio-vascular history, hypertension, and age have the lowest impact on the determination of the subject's health status. The main application of this new technology is the adoption of smart solutions (e.g., a mobile app) to customize the stratification of patients admitted to emergency departments (ED)s after a syncope event. Indeed, the adoption of these smart solutions gives the opportunity to customize risk stratification according to the specific clinical case (i.e., the patient's health status) and the physician's decision-making process (i.e., the desired levels of sensitivity and specificity). Moreover, a decision-making process based on these smart solutions might ensure a more effective use of available resources, improving the management of syncope patients and reducing the cost of inappropriate treatment and hospitalization.
急诊科的特点是需要在压力下快速诊断。为了选择最合适的治疗方法,科学协会提供了一系列支持决策的规则。这些规则的有效性影响着治疗的适宜性和患者的住院率。本研究分析了 1844 名患者的样本,重点关注晕厥后患者住院以预防严重短期结局的决策,提出了一种基于神经网络的新算法。人工神经网络是一种非参数技术,具有众所周知的泛化行为能力,因此可以通过预先选择的灵敏度和特异性来预测严重的短期结局。与传统模型相比,这项创新技术可以更好地预测严重的短期结局,因为它不需要特定的函数形式,即数据不应该按照特定的设计分布。基于我们的结果,创新模型可以以 100%的灵敏度和 79%的特异性预测住院,显著提高治疗的适宜性,从而提高医院的效率。根据 Garson 指数,最重要的变量是用力、无症状和患者性别。相反,心血管病史、高血压和年龄对确定患者健康状况的影响最小。这项新技术的主要应用是采用智能解决方案(如移动应用程序)来定制晕厥后急诊科(ED)患者的分层。实际上,采用这些智能解决方案有机会根据特定的临床病例(即患者的健康状况)和医生的决策过程(即所需的灵敏度和特异性水平)来定制风险分层。此外,基于这些智能解决方案的决策过程可以确保更有效地利用现有资源,改善晕厥患者的管理,并降低不适当治疗和住院的成本。