Rappolt-Schlichtmann Gabrielle, Boucher Alyssa R, Evans Miriam
EdTogether, Research & Innovation, Boston, MA.
Harvard Human Development and Psychology, Graduate School of Education, Cambridge, MA.
Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch. 2018 Oct 24;49(4):864-874. doi: 10.1044/2018_LSHSS-DYSLC-18-0031.
In this article, we explore the deficit view of dyslexia and consider how it may narrow research so as to hamper the progress of scientific discovery and constrain best practices to the detriment of the overall well-being and growth of students with dyslexia. We consider the neurodiversity view of dyslexia as an alternative to the deficit view and explore how strengths-based approaches such as Universal Design for Learning can be used to support the overall well-being and development of students with dyslexia. Practical strategies are provided for applying a strengths-based approach in the speech-language pathologist setting to support students with dyslexia.
We completed a focused literature review of the history of the deficit view of dyslexia, the alternate neurodiversity view, exceptional abilities related to dyslexia, and strategies for Universal Design for Learning.
Although the research literature that deals with visual-spatial affordances associated with dyslexia is limited, there is significant evidence that a strengths-based approach to learning experience design can be leveraged by practitioners to improve student self-development, motivation, and academic outcomes.
We find that further research is needed to explore strengths associated with dyslexia and argue that a shift in mindset from the deficit view toward the neurodiversity view is required to build the capacity of students with dyslexia to thrive in learning and life.
在本文中,我们探讨了阅读障碍的缺陷观,并思考它如何可能使研究范围变窄,从而阻碍科学发现的进展,并限制最佳实践,对阅读障碍学生的整体福祉和成长造成损害。我们将阅读障碍的神经多样性观视为缺陷观的一种替代观点,并探讨如何运用诸如通用学习设计等基于优势的方法来支持阅读障碍学生的整体福祉和发展。本文还提供了在言语语言病理学家环境中应用基于优势的方法来支持阅读障碍学生的实用策略。
我们针对阅读障碍的缺陷观历史、替代的神经多样性观、与阅读障碍相关的特殊能力以及通用学习设计策略完成了一次有针对性的文献综述。
尽管处理与阅读障碍相关的视觉空间条件的研究文献有限,但有大量证据表明,从业者可以利用基于优势的学习体验设计方法来改善学生的自我发展、动机和学业成绩。
我们发现需要进一步研究来探索与阅读障碍相关的优势,并认为需要从缺陷观向神经多样性观转变思维方式,以培养阅读障碍学生在学习和生活中茁壮成长的能力。