School of Political Science and Economics, and Research Institute for Environmental Economics and Management, Waseda University, Tokyo, Japan.
Faculty of Economics, Matsuyama University, Matsuyama, Japan.
PLoS One. 2018 Nov 26;13(11):e0207623. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0207623. eCollection 2018.
To attain cleaner air, it is important that authorities make informed decisions when selecting a strategy. Concentrations of particulate matter with an aerodynamic diameter of less than or equal to 2.5 μm (PM 2.5) are high in the Tokyo metropolitan area, even though concentrations of particulate matter with an aerodynamic diameter of less than or equal to 10 μm (PM10) have dropped dramatically since the implementation of the NOx-PM Act. Currently, monitored concentration levels continue to exceed the designated ambient air quality standard set by the Japanese Ministry of the Environment. To our knowledge, no study has investigated a cost-efficient strategy for reducing PM 2.5 concentration levels in the Tokyo metropolitan area. This is the first study to examine a proper control strategy for Japan by developing an integrated model that includes both aerosol and economic models. The simulation results show that prefectures in the Tokyo metropolitan area cannot achieve the standards by relying on their own efforts to reduce PM 2.5. That is, prefectural governments in the Tokyo metropolitan areas need to cooperate with prefectures outside of the area to improve their PM 2.5 concentration levels. Thus, we simulated policies under the assumption that emissions from other sources are reduced to levels such that the PM 2.5 concentration declines by approximately 18 μg/m3. We first simulated an efficient policy, i.e., the implementation of a pollution tax. We found that the total abatement cost to meet the air quality standard using the cost-efficient strategy is approximately 142.7 billion yen.
为了获得更清洁的空气,当选择策略时,当局做出明智的决策是很重要的。尽管自《NOx-PM 法案》实施以来,粒径小于或等于 10μm(PM10)的颗粒物浓度已大幅下降,但东京都地区粒径小于或等于 2.5μm(PM2.5)的颗粒物浓度仍然很高。目前,监测到的浓度水平仍持续超过日本环境省设定的指定环境空气质量标准。据我们所知,目前还没有研究探讨过降低东京都地区 PM2.5 浓度的成本效益策略。本研究首次通过开发包含气溶胶和经济模型的综合模型,来研究日本的适当控制策略。模拟结果表明,东京都地区的都道府县仅靠自身努力无法达到标准。也就是说,东京都地区的都道府县需要与该地区以外的都道府县合作,以改善其 PM2.5 浓度。因此,我们假设其他来源的排放量减少到 PM2.5 浓度下降约 18μg/m3 的水平,模拟了相关政策。我们首先模拟了一种有效的政策,即实施污染税。我们发现,使用成本效益策略来满足空气质量标准的总减排成本约为 1427 亿日元。