Brown University School of Public Health, 121 S Main St, Providence, RI 02903. Email:
Am J Manag Care. 2018 Dec 1;24(12):e386-e392.
Medicare Advantage (MA) plans have strong incentives to control costs, including postacute spending; however, to our knowledge, no research has examined the methods that MA plans use to control or reduce postacute costs. This study aimed to understand such MA plan efforts and the possible unintended consequences.
A multiple case study method was used.
We conducted 154 interviews with administrative and clinical staff working in 10 MA plans, 16 hospitals, and 25 skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) in 8 geographically diverse markets across the United States.
Participants discussed how MA plans attempted to reduce postacute care spending by controlling the SNF to which patients are discharged and SNF length of stay (LOS). Plans typically influenced SNF selection by providing patients with a list of facilities in which their care would be covered. To influence LOS, MA plans most commonly authorized patient stays in SNFs for a certain number of days and required that SNFs adhere to this limitation, but they did not provide guidance or assistance in ensuring that the LOS goals were met. Hospital and SNF responses to the largely authorization-based system were frequently negative, and participants expressed concerns about potential unintended consequences.
In their interactions with hospitals and SNFs, MA plans attempted to influence the choice of SNF and LOS to control postacute spending. However, exerting too much influence over hospitals and SNFs, as these results seem to indicate, may have the negative consequences of delayed hospital discharge and SNFs' avoidance of burdensome plans.
医疗保险优势(MA)计划有很强的控制成本的动机,包括后期医疗支出;然而,据我们所知,没有研究考察 MA 计划用来控制或降低后期医疗成本的方法。本研究旨在了解此类 MA 计划的努力及其可能产生的意外后果。
采用多案例研究方法。
我们对在美国 8 个地理分布不同的市场的 10 个 MA 计划、16 家医院和 25 家熟练护理设施(SNF)中的行政和临床工作人员进行了 154 次访谈。
参与者讨论了 MA 计划如何试图通过控制患者出院的 SNF 和 SNF 住院时间(LOS)来降低后期护理费用。计划通常通过向患者提供其护理将涵盖的设施清单来影响 SNF 的选择。为了影响 LOS,MA 计划最常见的做法是授权患者在 SNF 中停留一定天数,并要求 SNF 遵守这一限制,但他们没有提供指导或帮助来确保达到 LOS 目标。医院和 SNF 对这种主要基于授权的系统的反应往往是负面的,参与者对潜在的意外后果表示担忧。
在与医院和 SNF 的互动中,MA 计划试图影响 SNF 和 LOS 的选择,以控制后期医疗支出。然而,如这些结果所示,对医院和 SNF 施加过多的影响可能会产生负面后果,如延迟出院和 SNF 回避负担过重的计划。