Bowmer Alice, Mason Kathryn, Knight Julian, Welch Graham
UCL Institute of Education, University College London, London, United Kingdom.
Creative Futures, London, United Kingdom.
Front Psychol. 2018 Dec 20;9:2389. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2018.02389. eCollection 2018.
The impact of music interventions on the cognitive skills of young children has become the focus of a growing number of research studies in recent years. This study investigated the effect of weekly musicianship training on the executive function abilities of 3-to-4-year-old children at a London, United Kingdom preschool, using a two-phase experimental design. In Phase 1, 14 children (Group A) took part in eight weekly musicianship classes, provided by a specialist music teacher, while 25 children (Groups B and C combined) engaged in nursery free play. Results of this Phase showed Group A to have improved on two measures relating to planning and inhibition skills. During Phase 2, Group A continued with music classes, while Group B began music classes for the first time and Group C took part in an art intervention. Repeated measures ANOVA found no significant difference in performance improvement between the three participant groups during phase 2; however, the performance difference between groups was nearing significance for the peg tapping task ( = 0.06). The findings from this study contribute to current debates about the potential cognitive benefit of musical interventions, including important issues regarding intervention duration, experimental design, target age groups, executive function testing, and task novelty.
近年来,音乐干预对幼儿认知技能的影响已成为越来越多研究的焦点。本研究采用两阶段实验设计,调查了在英国伦敦一所幼儿园中,每周进行的音乐素养训练对3至4岁儿童执行功能能力的影响。在第一阶段,14名儿童(A组)参加了由专业音乐教师提供的为期八周的音乐素养课程,而25名儿童(B组和C组合并)则进行幼儿园自由游戏。该阶段的结果显示,A组在与计划和抑制技能相关的两项测量中有所改善。在第二阶段,A组继续上音乐课,而B组首次开始上音乐课,C组则参加艺术干预。重复测量方差分析发现,在第二阶段,三个参与组在表现改善方面没有显著差异;然而,在敲钉任务中,组间表现差异接近显著水平(P = 0.06)。本研究的结果为当前关于音乐干预潜在认知益处的争论做出了贡献,包括有关干预持续时间、实验设计、目标年龄组、执行功能测试和任务新颖性等重要问题。