Department of Anesthesia, Critical Care, and Pain Medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
Department of Anaesthesiology and Intensive Care Medicine, University Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany.
Anaesthesia. 2019 Apr;74(4):457-467. doi: 10.1111/anae.14517. Epub 2019 Jan 10.
It is unclear which criteria should be used to define readiness for tracheal extubation in the operating theatre. We studied the effects of desaturation in the operating theatre immediately after tracheal extubation on long-term outcomes. Performing a pre-specified, retrospective analysis of 71,025 cases involving previously independent adults undergoing non-cardiac surgery, we evaluated the association between desaturation events (oxygen saturation < 90%) within 10 min of tracheal extubation and adverse discharge (to a skilled nursing facility or long-term care facility). A total of 404 (12.3%) cases with, and 5035 (7.4%) cases without, early postoperative desaturation had an adverse discharge. Early postoperative desaturation was associated with higher odds of being discharged to a nursing facility (adjusted odds ratio 1.36 (95%CI 1.20-1.54); p < 0.001). Increased duration of desaturation augmented the effect (p for trend < 0.001). Desaturation was associated with a higher risk of respiratory, renal and cardiovascular complications as well as increased duration of hospital stay, postoperative intensive care unit admission frequency and cost. Several modifiable factors were associated with desaturation including: high intra-operative long-acting opioid administration; high neostigmine dose; high intra-operative inspired oxygen concentration; and low oxygen delivery immediately before tracheal extubation. There was substantial provider variability between anaesthetists in the incidence of postoperative desaturation unexplained by patient- and procedure-related factors. Early postoperative desaturation is a potentially preventable complication associated with a higher risk of adverse discharge disposition. Anaesthetists may consider developing guidelines to define tracheal extubation readiness that contain postoperative desaturation as an adverse outcome after tracheal extubation.
目前尚不清楚在手术室中应使用哪些标准来定义气管拔管的准备情况。我们研究了气管拔管后手术室即刻发生的脱氧对长期结果的影响。我们对 71025 例先前独立的非心脏手术成年患者进行了一项预先规定的回顾性分析,评估了气管拔管后 10 分钟内发生的脱氧事件(氧饱和度 < 90%)与不良出院(至熟练护理机构或长期护理机构)之间的关联。共有 404 例(12.3%)早期术后脱氧患者和 5035 例(7.4%)无早期术后脱氧患者出现不良出院。早期术后脱氧与被送往护理机构的可能性更高相关(校正优势比 1.36(95%CI 1.20-1.54);p<0.001)。脱氧持续时间延长增强了这种效果(p<0.001)。脱氧与呼吸、肾脏和心血管并发症风险增加以及住院时间延长、术后入住重症监护病房的频率和成本增加有关。一些可改变的因素与脱氧有关,包括术中长效阿片类药物的高用量;新斯的明剂量高;术中吸入氧气浓度高;以及气管拔管前即刻低氧输送。麻醉师之间在术后脱氧的发生率方面存在很大的差异,而这种差异不能用患者和手术相关因素来解释。术后早期脱氧是一种潜在可预防的并发症,与不良出院处置风险增加有关。麻醉师可能考虑制定定义气管拔管准备情况的指南,将气管拔管后脱氧作为不良后果之一。