Summerell Elizabeth, Harmon-Jones Cindy, Kelley Nicholas J, Peterson Carly K, Krstanoska-Blazeska Klimentina, Harmon-Jones Eddie
School of Psychology, The University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
Department of Psychology, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL, United States.
Front Psychol. 2019 Jan 8;9:2665. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2018.02665. eCollection 2018.
Past theory and research have suggested that motivationally intense affective states narrow cognitive scope. Research has also suggested manipulations that broaden cognitive scope reduce responses to appetitive positive affective stimuli and disgusting stimuli, thus suggesting that cognitive broadening reduces motivational intensity. This led to the hypothesis that cognitive broadening would reduce the approach-motivated negative emotion of anger. Seven studies assessed the effect of cognitive broadening on reported trait anger, state anger, attitudes toward anger, attributions of anger to ambiguous pictures, and accessibility of aggressive words. Results from individual studies found mixed support for these predictions. A meta-analysis, however, suggested a small but significant effect on trait anger/aggression and attitudes toward anger across studies. These results may indicate that cognitive scope, as manipulated in these studies, has a small effect on anger-related responses. Discussion speculates on potential explanations of these findings, and their importance for informing future research.
过去的理论和研究表明,动机强烈的情感状态会缩小认知范围。研究还表明,拓宽认知范围的操作会减少对积极情感刺激和厌恶刺激的反应,因此表明认知拓宽会降低动机强度。这导致了一个假设,即认知拓宽会减少由接近动机引发的负面情绪——愤怒。七项研究评估了认知拓宽对报告的特质愤怒、状态愤怒、对愤怒的态度、将愤怒归因于模糊图片以及攻击性词语的可及性的影响。个别研究的结果对这些预测的支持不一。然而,一项元分析表明,在各项研究中,认知拓宽对特质愤怒/攻击性以及对愤怒的态度有微小但显著的影响。这些结果可能表明,在这些研究中所操纵的认知范围对与愤怒相关的反应有微小影响。讨论推测了这些发现的潜在解释及其对为未来研究提供信息的重要性。