理解口服药和注射剂的“漏诊预约”:塞内加尔的一项混合方法研究。
Understanding 'missed appointments' for pills and injectables: a mixed methods study in Senegal.
作者信息
Cavallaro Francesca L, Duclos Diane, Cresswell Jenny A, Faye Sylvain, Macleod David, Faye Adama, Lynch Caroline A
机构信息
Department of Infectious Disease Epidemiology, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, UK.
Départment de sociologie, Université Cheikh Anta Diop, Dakar, Senegal.
出版信息
BMJ Glob Health. 2018 Dec 30;3(6):e000975. doi: 10.1136/bmjgh-2018-000975. eCollection 2018.
INTRODUCTION
High discontinuation rates of contraceptive methods have been documented in sub-Saharan Africa. However, little is known about gaps within individual episodes of method use, despite their implications for unintended pregnancies. The objective of this mixed methods study was to examine the prevalence of, and explore the factors contributing to, delays in repeat appointments for pills and injectables in Senegal.
METHODS
First, we constructed a longitudinal data set of women's contraceptive consultations using routine records from 67 facilities in Senegal. Consultations for pills and injectables were classified as on time, delayed or with unknown delay status based on time since previous appointment. We described the prevalence of delayed appointments and used backward stepwise regression to build a mixed-effects model to investigate risk factors for delay. Second, we conducted workshops with family planning (FP) providers, and indepth interviews and focus group discussions with women of reproductive age, to explore factors contributing to delays.
RESULTS
Almost one-third (30%) of appointments for pills and injectables were delayed, resulting in risk of pregnancy. Previous delay, pill use, lower educational level, higher parity, third and subsequent visits, and Islamic faith were independently predictive of delays (p<0.04 for all). Although women's 'forgetfulness' was initially mentioned as the main reason for delays by women and providers, examining the routines around appointment attendance revealed broader contextual barriers to timely refills-particularly widespread covert use, illiteracy, financial cost of FP services and limited availability of FP services.
CONCLUSION
Delays in obtaining repeat pills and injections are common among contraceptive users in Senegal, exposing women to unintended pregnancies. Strategies to reduce such delays should move beyond a narrow focus on individual women to consider contraceptive behaviour within the broader socioeconomic and health systems context. In particular, effective interventions addressing low acceptability of contraception and appointment reminder strategies in high illiteracy contexts are needed.
引言
撒哈拉以南非洲地区避孕药具停用率较高。然而,尽管方法使用的各个阶段对意外怀孕有影响,但对这些阶段中的差距却知之甚少。这项混合方法研究的目的是调查塞内加尔口服避孕药和注射剂重复预约延迟的患病率,并探索导致延迟的因素。
方法
首先,我们利用塞内加尔67家医疗机构的常规记录构建了一个关于女性避孕咨询的纵向数据集。根据距上次预约的时间,将口服避孕药和注射剂的咨询分为按时、延迟或延迟状态未知。我们描述了延迟预约的患病率,并使用向后逐步回归建立了一个混合效应模型来调查延迟的风险因素。其次,我们与计划生育提供者举办了研讨会,并与育龄妇女进行了深入访谈和焦点小组讨论,以探索导致延迟的因素。
结果
几乎三分之一(30%)的口服避孕药和注射剂预约被延迟,这增加了怀孕风险。之前的延迟、口服避孕药的使用、较低的教育水平、较高的生育次数、第三次及后续就诊以及伊斯兰教信仰是延迟的独立预测因素(所有p<0.04)。尽管女性和提供者最初都提到女性的“健忘”是延迟的主要原因,但研究预约就诊的常规情况发现,及时补货存在更广泛的背景障碍,尤其是普遍存在的隐蔽使用、文盲、计划生育服务的经济成本以及计划生育服务的可及性有限。
结论
在塞内加尔,避孕药具使用者中重复获取口服避孕药和注射剂的延迟很常见,这使女性面临意外怀孕的风险。减少此类延迟的策略不应仅仅局限于个别女性,而应在更广泛的社会经济和卫生系统背景下考虑避孕行为。特别是,需要在高文盲背景下采取有效的干预措施,解决避孕可接受性低的问题以及预约提醒策略。