Division of Nephrology and Hypertension, Department of Medicine, Mayo Clinic, Scottsdale, Arizona, USA.
Center of Science of Health Care Delivery, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota, USA.
BMJ Open. 2019 Jan 28;9(1):e024671. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-024671.
Native Americans suffer from lower rates of kidney transplantation compared with whites. Our goal was to elicit patients' perceptions of and attitudes about kidney transplant and the impact of financial burden and cultural taboos.
This is an exploratory qualitative interview study of 12 Native American patients recruited after completion of the kidney transplant evaluation.
Semistructured interviews were conducted. Interviews were coded using inductive methods, followed by interpretive coding by the investigators.
Thematic analysis revealed the following themes: (1) experience with kidney transplant education by the healthcare team; (2) cultural beliefs regarding kidney transplant; (3) personal motivation and attitude towards kidney transplant; (4) financial burden of kidney transplant and post-transplant care and (5) attitude about living donation.Most participants were educated about transplant as a treatment option after dialysis initiation. All patients in this study recognised that some taboos exist about the process of organ procurement and transplantation; however, the traditional views did not negatively impact their decision to pursue kidney transplant evaluation. Patients shared the common theme of preferring an organ from a living rather than a deceased person; however, the majority did not have a living donor and preferred not to receive an organ from a family member. Most patients did not perceive transplant-related cost as negatively impacting their attitude about receiving a transplant even for patients with below poverty level income.
Native American patients presenting for kidney transplant were less likely to be educated about transplant before dialysis initiation; did not perceive financial burden and cultural beliefs were not discussed as obstacles to transplant. While a living donor was the preferred option, enthusiasm for living donation from family members was limited.
与白人相比,美洲原住民接受肾移植的比例较低。我们的目标是了解患者对肾移植的看法和态度,以及经济负担和文化禁忌的影响。
这是一项对 12 名接受完肾移植评估的美洲原住民患者进行的探索性定性访谈研究。
进行半结构化访谈。使用归纳法对访谈进行编码,然后由研究人员进行解释性编码。
主题分析揭示了以下主题:(1)医疗团队提供的肾移植教育体验;(2)关于肾移植的文化信仰;(3)对肾移植的个人动机和态度;(4)肾移植和移植后护理的经济负担;(5)对活体捐赠的态度。大多数参与者在开始透析后接受了关于移植作为治疗选择的教育。本研究中的所有患者都认识到器官获取和移植过程中存在一些禁忌;然而,传统观点并没有对他们进行肾移植评估的决定产生负面影响。患者分享了更喜欢来自活体而不是死者器官的共同主题;然而,大多数人没有活体供体,也不希望从家庭成员那里接受器官。大多数患者认为移植相关费用不会对他们接受移植的态度产生负面影响,即使是收入低于贫困水平的患者也是如此。
接受肾移植的美洲原住民患者在开始透析前接受的移植教育较少;他们不认为经济负担和文化信仰是移植的障碍。虽然活体供体是首选,但家庭成员对活体捐赠的热情有限。