Center for Health Systems Research, National Institute of Public Health Mexico, Cuernavaca Morelos, México.
PLoS One. 2019 Jan 30;14(1):e0210319. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0210319. eCollection 2019.
Family planning (FP) is one of the key services provided by health care systems. Extending beyond matters of sexual and reproductive health, its area of influence impacts directly on the development of individuals and nations. After 60 years of intense FP activities in Mexico, and in light of recent restructuring of health service supply and financing, services need to be assessed from a user perspective.
Based on a comprehensive conceptual framework, this article assesses the quality of the FP services provided by the Mexican Ministry of Health (MoH). Analysis considers not only accessibility and availability but also the users' perceptions of the care process, particularly as regards the interpersonal relations they experience with staff and the type of information they are provided.
This study used a descriptive, qualitative design based on maximum variation sampling in six Mexican states. It included visits to 12 clinics in urban and rural areas. Thematic analysis was performed on 86 semi-structured interviews administered to FP service users.
While access was described by users as "easy," their experiences revealed normalized barriers. One of our key findings referred to inverse availability, meaning that the contraceptive methods available were generally not the ones preferred by users, with their selection therefore being shaped by shortage of supplies. Challenges included disrespect for the free choice of FP users and coercion during consultations for contraception post obstetric event. Finally, information provided to users left considerable room for improvement.
After six decades of FP service supply, results indicate a series of quality issues that may lie at the heart of the unmet demand reported in the literature. Based on a comprehensive conceptual scheme, the present study analyzes the quality of services, highlighting areas for improvement that should be considered by the MoH in future efforts.
计划生育(FP)是医疗保健系统提供的关键服务之一。它的影响领域不仅涉及性健康和生殖健康,还直接影响个人和国家的发展。在墨西哥开展了 60 年的计划生育活动之后,以及最近对卫生服务供应和融资进行了重组,需要从用户的角度评估服务。
基于全面的概念框架,本文评估了墨西哥卫生部(MoH)提供的 FP 服务的质量。分析不仅考虑了可及性和可用性,还考虑了用户对护理过程的看法,特别是他们与工作人员之间的人际关系以及所提供的信息类型。
本研究采用描述性、定性设计,在墨西哥六个州进行了最大变异抽样。它包括对城市和农村地区的 12 个诊所的访问。对 86 名 FP 服务使用者进行的半结构化访谈进行了主题分析。
虽然用户描述访问是“容易”的,但他们的经验揭示了正常化的障碍。我们的一个关键发现是反向可用性,这意味着可用的避孕方法通常不是用户首选的方法,因此其选择受到供应短缺的影响。挑战包括不尊重 FP 用户的自由选择和在产后避孕咨询中进行强制。最后,向用户提供的信息有很大的改进空间。
在提供 FP 服务 60 年后,结果表明存在一系列质量问题,这些问题可能是文献中报道的未满足需求的核心。本研究基于全面的概念框架,分析了服务质量,强调了 MoH 在未来努力中应考虑的改进领域。