Department of Pathology, Immunology and Laboratory Medicine, University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida.
Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota.
J Neuropathol Exp Neurol. 2019 Apr 1;78(4):291-293. doi: 10.1093/jnen/nly131.
The legal system of the United States is complex, with nuances that are particular to its many jurisdictions. The neuropathologist may professionally interact with the legal system in both criminal and civil proceedings as either a fact or expert witness, and in rare instances as a defendant. The nature of the legal issue at hand will define the pathologist's role and determine what actions are required or requested. The intersection of neuropathology and the laws governing quality assurance may be less defined as legal statutes vary by state; although, the general principles of privilege, peer review, and confidentiality remain similar. Aside from a forensic pathology fellowship, there is often little in the way of our training to prepare us for our potential roles in the courtroom. This article serves as a review for the neuropathologist's role as a witness, the legal proceedings that you may participate in, and the intersection between quality assurance and law.
美国的法律体系复杂,在其众多司法管辖区内存在特定的细微差别。神经病理学家可能会以事实或专家证人的身份,在刑事和民事诉讼中与法律体系进行专业互动,在极少数情况下,也可能成为被告。手头法律问题的性质将决定病理学家的角色,并确定需要或请求采取哪些行动。神经病理学与质量管理法规的交叉可能不太明确,因为州法律法规各不相同;尽管,特权、同行评审和保密的一般原则仍然相似。除了法医病理学奖学金外,我们的培训通常很少有准备我们在法庭上的潜在角色的内容。本文旨在回顾神经病理学家作为证人的角色、您可能参与的法律程序,以及质量保证与法律之间的交叉点。