Giromini Luciano, Barbosa Fernando, Coga Giulia, Azeredo Andreia, Viglione Donald J, Zennaro Alessandro
Department of Psychology, University of Turin, Turin, Italy.
Faculty of Psychology and Education Sciences, University of Porto, Porto, Portugal.
Appl Neuropsychol Adult. 2020 Nov-Dec;27(6):504-516. doi: 10.1080/23279095.2019.1570929. Epub 2019 Feb 17.
This study tested whether combining the Inventory of Problems - 29 (IOP-29) with the Test of Memory Malingering (TOMM) would increase sensitivity in the detection of experimentally feigned mental health problems, compared to using either test alone. Additionally, it also evaluated (a) the effects of administration order of these two tests and (b) the cultural and linguistic applicability of these tests to a European Portuguese population. The IOP-29 and TOMM were administered to a community sample of 100 nonclinical, adult volunteers from Portugal, with the instruction to feign mental health problems. Half were instructed to feign mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) symptoms, half were instructed to feign major depression. Administration order had no effects on the tests' scores, and both measures produced excellent sensitivity values, ranging from .82 to .98 for the TOMM, and from .88 to 1.00 for the IOP-29, when using standard a priori cutoff scores. More importantly, combining the results of TOMM with those of IOP-29 notably increased sensitivity compared to using either test alone. This study thus supports the use of the IOP-29 together with the TOMM in multimethod symptom validity assessments and provides initial evidence that both tests can be used also in Portugal.
本研究旨在测试,与单独使用《问题清单-29项》(IOP-29)或《记忆伪装测验》(TOMM)相比,将这两项测验结合使用是否会提高对实验性伪装心理健康问题的检测敏感度。此外,研究还评估了:(a)这两项测验施测顺序的影响,以及(b)这两项测验对葡萄牙欧洲人群的文化和语言适用性。对来自葡萄牙的100名非临床成年志愿者组成的社区样本施测IOP-29和TOMM,并指导他们伪装心理健康问题。其中一半人被指导伪装轻度创伤性脑损伤(mTBI)症状,另一半人被指导伪装重度抑郁症。施测顺序对测验分数没有影响,使用标准的先验临界分数时,两项测验都产生了出色的敏感度值,TOMM的敏感度值范围为0.82至0.98,IOP-29的敏感度值范围为0.88至1.00。更重要的是,与单独使用任何一项测验相比,将TOMM和IOP-29的结果结合起来显著提高了敏感度。因此,本研究支持在多方法症状效度评估中同时使用IOP-29和TOMM,并提供了初步证据表明这两项测验在葡萄牙也可使用。