Stubbs Evan B, Fisher Morris A, Miller Clara M, Jelinek Christine, Butler Jolene, McBurney Conor, Collins Eileen G
Research Service, Department of Veterans Affairs, Edward Hines Jr. VA Hospital, Hines, IL, United States.
Department of Ophthalmology, Stritch School of Medicine, Loyola University Chicago Health Sciences Division, Maywood, IL, United States.
Front Neurosci. 2019 Feb 11;13:51. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2019.00051. eCollection 2019.
Physical exercise is an essential adjunct to the management of patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus. Therapeutic interventions that improve blood flow to peripheral nerves, such as exercise, may slow the progression of neuropathy in the diabetic patient. This randomized clinical trial was conducted to determine whether a structured program of aerobic, isokinetic strength, or the combination of aerobic-isokinetic strength exercise intervention alters peripheral nerve function in glycemic-controlled diabetic patients with advanced length-dependent distal symmetric polyneuropathy. Forty-five patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus exhibiting tight glycemic control (HbA intergroup range 7.2-8.0%) were randomized by block design across four experimental groups: sedentary controls ( = 12), aerobic exercise ( = 11), isokinetic strength ( = 11), or the combination of aerobic-isokinetic strength training ( = 11). Patients randomized to training groups exercised 3× per week for 12 weeks, whereas patients randomized to the sedentary control group received standard of care. To minimize attention and educational bias, all patients attended a 12-session health promotion educational series. At baseline, immediately following intervention, and again at 12-week post-intervention, detailed nerve conduction studies were conducted as a primary outcome measure. At these same intervals, all patients completed as secondary measures quantitative sensory testing, symptom-limited treadmill stress tests, and a Short-Form 36-Veterans Questionnaire (SF-36V). Of the 45 patients randomized into this study, 37 (82%) had absent sural nerve responses, 19 (42%) had absent median sensory nerve responses, and 17 (38%) had absent ulnar sensory nerve responses. By comparison, responses from tibial nerves were absent in only three (7%) subjects while responses from peroneal nerves were absent in five (11%) subjects. Eleven (92%) of 12 patients that had volunteered to be biopsied exhibited abnormal levels of epidermal nerve fiber densities. Exercise, regardless of type, did not alter sensory or motor nerve electrodiagnostic findings among those patients exhibiting measurable responses (). There was, however, a modest ( = 0.01) beneficial effect of exercise on sensory nerve function ( Test). Importantly, the beneficial effect of exercise on sensory nerve function was enhanced ( = 0.03) during the post-intervention interval. In addition, three of six patients that had undergone exercise intervention exhibited a marked 1.9 ± 0.3-fold improvement in epidermal nerve fiber density. By comparison, none of three sedentary patients whom agreed to be biopsied a second time showed improvement in epidermal nerve fiber density. Compared to baseline values within groups, and compared with sedentary values across groups, neither aerobic, isokinetic strength, or the combination of aerobic-isokinetic strength exercise intervention altered peak oxygen uptake. Patients that underwent aerobic or the combined aerobic-isokinetic strength exercise intervention, however, demonstrated an increase in treadmill test duration that was sustained over the 12-week post-intervention period. A 12-week course of physical exercise, regardless of type, does not alter sensory or motor nerve electrodiagnostic findings. In a subset of patients, a short-term structured program of aerobic exercise may selectively improve sensory nerve fiber function. Large-scale exercise lifestyle intervention trials are warranted to further evaluate the impact of aerobic exercise on sensory nerve fiber function in diabetic neuropathic patients. www.ClinicalTrials.gov, identifier NCT00955201.
体育锻炼是2型糖尿病患者治疗的重要辅助手段。改善外周神经血流的治疗干预措施,如运动,可能会减缓糖尿病患者神经病变的进展。本随机临床试验旨在确定有氧、等速力量训练或有氧-等速力量训练相结合的结构化项目是否会改变血糖控制良好且患有晚期长度依赖性远端对称性多发性神经病变的糖尿病患者的外周神经功能。45例血糖控制良好(糖化血红蛋白组间范围7.2 - 8.0%)的2型糖尿病患者通过区组设计随机分为四个实验组:久坐对照组(n = 12)、有氧运动组(n = 11)、等速力量训练组(n = 11)或有氧-等速力量训练组合组(n = 11)。随机分配到训练组的患者每周锻炼3次,共12周,而随机分配到久坐对照组的患者接受标准护理。为尽量减少关注和教育偏差,所有患者都参加了为期12节的健康促进教育课程。在基线、干预后即刻以及干预后12周,进行详细的神经传导研究作为主要结局指标。在相同时间间隔,所有患者完成定量感觉测试、症状限制平板运动压力测试和简短36项退伍军人问卷(SF - 36V)作为次要指标。在随机纳入本研究的45例患者中,37例(82%)腓肠神经反应缺失,19例(42%)正中感觉神经反应缺失,17例(38%)尺神经感觉神经反应缺失。相比之下,仅3例(7%)受试者胫神经无反应,5例(11%)受试者腓总神经无反应。12例自愿接受活检的患者中有11例(92%)表皮神经纤维密度水平异常。在有可测量反应的患者中,无论何种类型的运动,均未改变感觉或运动神经电诊断结果()。然而运动对感觉神经功能有适度(P = 0.01)的有益作用(检验)。重要的是,运动对感觉神经功能的有益作用在干预后期间增强(P = 0.03)。此外,6例接受运动干预的患者中有3例表皮神经纤维密度显著提高1.9 ± 0.3倍。相比之下,3例同意再次接受活检的久坐患者中,无一例表皮神经纤维密度有所改善。与组内基线值相比,以及与组间久坐值相比,有氧、等速力量训练或有氧-等速力量训练组合干预均未改变峰值摄氧量。然而,接受有氧运动或有氧-等速力量训练组合干预的患者在干预后12周期间,平板运动测试持续时间有所增加。为期12周的体育锻炼,无论何种类型,均不会改变感觉或运动神经电诊断结果。在一部分患者中,短期的有氧运动结构化项目可能会选择性地改善感觉神经纤维功能。有必要进行大规模的运动生活方式干预试验,以进一步评估有氧运动对糖尿病神经病变患者感觉神经纤维功能的影响。www.ClinicalTrials.gov,标识符NCT00955201